Just as a quick aside, the copyright part of U.S. Const art. I, § 8, cl. 8, is actually the phrase 'Science', and not 'the useful Arts.'
Edit: I know the misuse of the 'useful arts' phrase was from the blog post itself, and replied to this post only because it was the first I saw that mentioned that part of the post.
Now, I am not sure how that wikipedia article refutes what I said. If it is because the article refers to U.S. Const, art I, § 8, cl. 8 as the "Copyright Clause", you can also see under the heading "Other Terms" the article refers to that same clause also as the "Copyright and Patent Clause", "Patent and Copyright Clause", "Copyright Clause", "Patent Clause", "Intellectual Property Clause", and the "Progress Clause." Copyright and Patent Clause is probably the best name for it as the clause deals with both subject matters, (I dislike calling it the Intellectual Property clause, because other areas of IP, such as trademark and geographic indicators fall under other clauses).
Additionally, that article actually supports what I said. In the first paragraph under "Effect", the article discusses how "[s]ome terms in the clause are used in archaic meanings, potentially confusing modern readers." Specifically it discusses how "useful Arts" refers to people skilled in manufacturing crafts and not artistic pursuits, and how "Science" addresses general knowledge and not scientific inquiry.
While wikipedia may not be the best source for this, other wikipedia articles may be illustrative on the original meanings of these words, such as the article on the term Useful art itself. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_art)
But again, the cool thing, is that we can discover this connection ourselves by just looking at the text of the clause. In looking at the clauses construction we can see an A and B pattern being followed. Where A refers to copyrights and B refers to patents. Here is the clause with the A and B pattern annotated.
"To promote the progress of (A) science and (B) useful arts, by securing for limited times to (A) authors and (B) inventors the exclusive right to their respective (A) writings and (B) discoveries;"
Learning this distinction was actually helpful to me in my following coursework, as it helped me understand why in patent law we use phrases like "prior art" and "person of ordinary skill in the art" and why copyright law applies to works outside of creative endeavors, such as scientific journal articles or news articles.
Now, as far as legal effect, these words have very little to do with how we apply the laws of Copyright and Patent. They merely explain the reasons why we empower the federal government with the power to pass laws affecting copyrights and patents. Pass any constitutional challenge that the copyright laws and patent laws are beyond Congress's power, U.S. art I, § 8, cl. 8 is little help in assessing a copyright or patent case.
Also, doesn't the US have international agreements regulating copyright, and couldn't those protections be much more broad than the constitutional protections anyways?
Some areas of law are more objective standards - using bright line rules in lieu of balancing tests, but you are correct there is always an element of subjectivity in the application of facts to law no matter the standard.
1st Amendment law is notoriously full of balancing tests, probably best exemplified by Justice Stewart:
"I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that."
Given the community standard stuff I'm not so srue.
What would be interesting, would be if the Wong didn't just claim that porn isn't useful, and so it isn't copyrightable (which seems like a losing strategy), but rather claimed that the porn in question was criminally obscene, and that the criminal nature of the work rendered the copyright void. Ironically, a successful defense would then potentially open you up to some sort of obscenity trafficking charge. Hoisted on your own petard as it were.
Unfortunately for Wong, this appears to be just run of the mill heterosexual porn, so unlikely to be ruled obscene. So the moral of the story is to download only the really really kinky stuff.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Hardcore#Prosecutions