The first is very unrealistic because this is a market and ARM chip makers aren't Santa Clause, the second seems very, very unrealistic, because Intel already has the most efficient "big iron"-ish CPUs (just compare SAP benchmarks vs. power usage of Intel-based vs. POWER-based systems, for instance), and have been under continuous pressure for more than a decade to make things more efficient (because energy use and costs following from it are a major cost factor for all of Intel's biggest server customers). That alone doesn't mean that it's not possible to be better, of course, but it's a strong hint that if no one else managed to get close to Intel there that it maybe is a hard thing to pull off. In any case I think a four-fold efficiency increase is expecting way too much.
10 % better power efficiency at the same performance level per unit would already signal a huge win for ARM.
These are servers, not hypedisruptionmarkets. Not once where there 400 % efficiency increases in a single generation of anything.
I'm not sure the upfront effort/cost would be worth it for that savings alone, especially when Intel will just come along and say they'll have that savings in an x86 chip in 9 months without any software dev required.
What this could do for the big DC companies though, is provide them a lever to keep Intel on that path. That lever alone might be worth all the dev effort required to support 2 architectures in a DC for some customers - and even if it's not worth it empirically, it may make them feel like it is.
1) One quarter the price for equivalent performance for server task (e.g. 500 USD for 48-core Qualcomm vs 2000 USD for 16-core (32-thread) Intel). E.g. the problem of 48-core Cavium ARM chip was poor performance, that could be fixed by Qualcomm, with better IPC (big enough L3 cache, and 3 or 4 OooE).
2) One quarter the power usage
3) Reliable and affordable motherboards
4) Devices at similar price vs Intel ecosystem (high performance Ethernet, Infiniband, PCI-E SDD, etc.)