News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by krschultz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:02PM (#1319976)
Lies damn lies and statistics.

1) Does it surprise anyone that they have 5x as many men as women as users? I wonder if you broke down by occupation what percentage of their users are software developers and engineers compared to others?

2) It's not a random sample. While they say "The data for this report was compiled from 8,000 randomly selected men and women", it is not of all people, it is of their users. Those are two vastly different things.

3) "All this adds up to huge differences in the amount of knowledge work men get done compared to women. Our data shows women only work 76% of the time that men do. Interestingly, the National Committee on Pay Equity found that women earn 77% of what their male counter parts do." is one of the dumbest comments I have ever seen in my life.

THEIR TOOL DOESN'T CATCH ALL WORK. I stopped using it because it is utterly useless if you step away from the computer and are productive in that time. They are saying "Our data shows women only work 76% of the time that men do. [in front of computers]" Dropping out the in front of computers part is huge. Is the President of the United States a knowledge worker? Because he doesn't have a computer on his desk and therefore would be 0% as productive as someone doing data entry according to this methodology.

For that matter, me sitting in front of my computer all day with Eclipse open (no matter how much I actually commit) is more productive than my dad, a CEO, who spends a lot of his time with a pad of paper out talking to people. Hmmmmmm.

I understand that this tool has its place, but to say something so outrageously false really casts the company as a whole in a bad light. Blogging this was poor judgement. At best it is just some dumb people who don't understand data, at worst it is offensive.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by webwright on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:22PM (#1320011)
I think you should re-read the post. The phrase "on his/her/their computers" is repeated 4 times in the (fairly short) post. I think it's pretty clear that this doesn't apply when comparing a pad/paper CEO and an engineer. And we very purposefully didn't draw any conclusions (though we did admittedly ask leading questions to fuel the conversation!).

We say a few times in the comments that this could well be a reflection of the types of jobs that the 4000 women have compared to the 4000 men-- they may have more social jobs or more "afk" jobs. It'd be an interesting followup to grab 1000 female engineers and 1000 man engineers to see if the differences hold up. I don't know if it will, but what if it did? Would it be so horrible if women were less suited for multitasking and knowledge work? Because they sure as heck are better at a lot of other things. They're, on average, smarter than men. They have better reflexes. Check out "Is there anything good about men" - great essay: http://denisdutton.com/baumeister.htm

If they WERE less suited for it, it would be interesting to see how much culture and education influenced their suitability. i.e. Does the difference fade away if you correct for educational differences, etc.

At the end of the day, it's just an interesting chunk of from a single web service that has a very strong bias towards geeky users.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by xiaoma on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @04:10AM (#1320649)
I couldn't agree more. I've seen countless pieces with flimsier statistics than this claiming that women are in some way more intelligent, more rational, or more ethical than men.

If a study finds that more parts of a man's brain activate when he does X task, the headline reads that women can process it more efficiently and only need to use a small portion of their brains.

If a study finds that more parts of a woman's brain activate when she does X task, the headline reads that women are able to recruit more of their brains and do the task holistically.

This piece was a breath of fresh air.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by jquery on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:30PM (#1320030)
Lose a customer gain a customer. I applaud your bravery.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by krschultz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:35PM (#1320041)
These quotes are the ones you should look at:

"4) Women spend fewer hours on their computers Evidently, there’s a reason they are called “man” hours. On average, male information workers spend 14% more time per day working on their computers than women do."

Glossing over a lot in that quote

Or how about trying to make your data way more scientific than it is (based on your own comments it is clear you don't personally understand this concept)

"About the data: RescueTime provides a tool to allow individuals and businesses to track their time and attention to see where their days go (and to help them get more productive!). We have hundreds of millions of man hours of second-by-second attention data from hundreds of thousands of users around the world, tracking both inside and outside the browser. The data for this report was compiled from 8,000 randomly selected men and women."

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by krschultz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:28PM (#1320025)
At the end of the day, you flung up some crap on your company's offical blog that is both horribly misinformed from a statistical perspective and about the subject you are posting on.

Is that professional? Is that good for your company? If I were an investor I'd be PISSED. If I hadn't canned my account to your site about 6 weeks after I made it (cool tool by the way, just missed too much of my work since I don't spend all day on my computer), I'd be canceling it today. And I sure as hell won't ever be trying it again. And I'll specifically be recommending against it.

At my startup we had a discussion about using data from our users to draw attention the way you are trying to here (and Mint.com has very successfully done in the past as just one example). The problem is you have to recognize where the mine fields are.

Replace every single place you used the word "women" and replace it with "black people" and see if it is offensive to you yet.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by webwright on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:39PM (#1320051)
I'm sorry that you're angry.

For what it's worth, we worked pretty hard to make this as statistically solid as we could with the dataset that we had. The subject we're posting on is "How 4,000 men differ from 4,000 women in RescueTime". While the data might lead to some interesting questions, I don't think anyone would assume that this is necessarily a reflection of a broader population (any more than Mint's data was).

I think your "black people" example is interesting. If we were comparing designers to developers, would you be so incensed? Yours is literally the first actually angry response all day. Is it possible that you're overreacting?

In terms of business effect, signups today have been abnormally high and cancellations have been slightly to the low side.

It was meant to be provocative, but so far this hasn't ended up being a mine field. Again, sorry that we've upset you.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by araneae on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @11:27PM (#1320251)
I have to agree that the post wasn't written very sensitively.

Here are the following red flag passages, for me, at least:

"From what I can tell, the 23rd chromosome has a pretty amazing impact on the way people use computers." -Drawing a conclusion from data you admit has large sampling issues.

"Women spend more time socializing and shopping" - You did not mention any comparative "frivolous" activities that men might take part in more than women; say, gaming.

"Evidently, there’s a reason they are called “man” hours." - Using a limited data set to large conclusions about female working habits in all contexts

Generally, the whole thing was both hyperbolic and quite inflammatory.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by staunch on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @01:07AM (#1320380)
The only part I cringed on was the "man hours" line. Just does not work in text.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by krschultz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:52PM (#1320085)
I'm not the only angry response you've gotten today. Ctrl+F this thread for "hackermom", do you think she liked your post? Just one among several.

I know YOU don't believe that women are 77% as productive as men and that explains the pay gap, I get your tongue in cheek tone.

The problem is that there are lots of people who use these half cocked "pieces of data" as part of larger arguments and it is exacerbated by a statement like "a random sample of 8,000 people" when clearly, this is not a random sample. It should say "this is not a scientific sample", because it isn't.

This is how we got birthers, "logical racists", and conspiracy theorists.

Perhaps I am more sensitive to it, I took a class on gender studies, I hung out with some feminists, my wife makes a lot of money (more than I for a while, and she wasn't on a computer nearly as much as I).

I think I just get mad at misapplied statistics, the lack of distinction between correlation and causation, and people saying ridiculous things to get attention (of which this does all 3). Suffice to say fivethirtyeight.com is one of my "read every day" sites.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by derefr on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @10:40PM (#1320157)
Please don't blame me for inventing a gun that someone later uses to shoot you. The problem is with the sophists misapplying others' research, trying to find evidence to support their pre-formed conclusions instead of following the evidence where it may lead; the problem is not with the researchers themselves, or the objective facts they produce.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by MichaelSalib on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @12:27AM (#1320322)
Um, what? I've seen research. I've done research. And this is not research. Research implies some knowledge of statistics and familiarity with the relevant science. Just because a three year old child likes to play with toy planes does not mean they're a pilot. And just because some software geeks like to play with numbers does not mean they have any clue what they're doing.

This is not the boy scouts. You don't get a research merit badge just for showing up and crunching some numbers.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by pg on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @12:40AM (#1320337)
Speaking as one of their investors, I'm not pissed at all. In fact I've found political correctness is if anything inversely correlated with success in startups. It seems to derive from a combination of cowardice and conventional mindedness, which are the last two qualities you'd want in a startup founder.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by jquery on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:28PM (#1320027)
One could say the same thing about studies that purport to show a huge market-gravity-defying wage/gender gap.*

* it's only important because our President is in favor of establishing a government organization to determine "fair" pay.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by krschultz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:32PM (#1320039)
Well it is a fact that there is a wage gap in the US if you look at the overall average of men and women. Rarely if you look at a man and a woman in the same job is there a huge pay gap. Those are two different things and the latter was what people used to complain about, the former is what people complain about today. But there are lots of reasons why this is the case.

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/women-earn-less-than-men-bu...

None of those reasons have to do with productivity.

Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by jquery on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:37PM (#1320047)
If women really are a discount, why hire a man at all? That is the question I have never seen answered convincingly.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by krschultz on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @09:42PM (#1320056)
I'm agreeing with you, I don't think the wage gap (today) is talking about two equally qualified people getting paid different amounts for the same job, although it does happen in some rare circumstances it doesn't account for a 20% difference. That is mostly related to personal decisions on what career to choose, work/life balance, etc.
Re:RescueTime (YC 08) Data: Are Men more Productive than Wom... by MichaelSalib on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @12:31AM (#1320326)
Maybe women have to settle for less because employers consistently underrate their competence. Since most employers want competent people, if they irrationally believe that women are less competent, they will be less likely to hire women, even at a discount.

In general, statements of the form "but that's impossible since all people act as rational utility maximizing agents" demonstrate an ignorance of the many many studies showing that people do not act completely rationally pretty much all the time.