News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brain, Mind, Body and the Disease of Addiction by DanBC on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:31PM (#13196491)
Addiction has a fairly well defined meaning, that doesn't apply to a bunch of stuff (sex, gambling) or to problematic but less severe than addiction stuff like harmful drinking. This is why people tend to talk about dependence instead.

There are 4 aspects to dependence.

1) Tolerance

2) Pre-occupation

3) Craving

4) Continuing when you know it's harmful

Here you'd have people who'd continue the activity beyond the slight decrease in life expectancy because, as you quote, there's an element of compulsivity.

All addiction is harmful misuse. Not all harmful misuse is addiction.

Re:Brain, Mind, Body and the Disease of Addiction by md224 on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:00PM (#13196777)
Your definition of dependence seems to assume there is harm involved, but I can think of a lot of dependencies that are either beneficial or neutral. Are you referring specifically to psychological dependence, as opposed to physical dependence?
Re:Brain, Mind, Body and the Disease of Addiction by crawfordcomeaux on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:50PM (#13197626)
I think "dependence" as described above is a softer way to address addictions. I'm guessing people use it to avoid the stigma of addiction & because so many definitions of addiction (including the one in the DSM) only address drugs/alcohol.

I think that's kind of what the article's looking to address is we need to broaden the definition of addiction.

I don't think what he's saying is meant to be applicable to people who suffer from chronic pain from irreparable/incurable afflictions & so are physically dependent on drugs to alleviate their pain.

I do think there's harm in prescribing drugs to alleviate chronic pain in sufferers whose pain was triggered by something long since treated & now persists as a learned pattern in their mind. Treating that condition with drugs instead of mental techniques to unlearn the pattern is like putting Neosporin on an open wound that won't heal shut without stitches.