News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by JamilD on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:46PM (#13195126)
The drone was operating in international waters. And despite the name, only a small part of the South China Sea is in China's Exclusive Economic Zone.

Much of the sea is closer to other countries (like the Philippines and Vietnam), but China lays unilateral claim to many of the uninhabited islands.

edit: A map, for reference: http://www.abc.net.au/cm/lb/5464160/data/south-china-sea-map...

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by elefanten on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:57PM (#13195221)
And this incident in particular happened 100 miles off the western coast of the Philippines, where the US has a sanctioned naval base. That's far closer to the Phillipines than anywhere else, even the disputed Spratly Islands.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:52PM (#13195172)
This is one interpretation of a widely disputed issue.

Many people like to underwrite this opinion with the Hague Tribunal findings, but unfortunately UNCLOS itself (article 299) states that it has no authority to decide territorial cases.

In any case, the claims to the islands in the South China Sea are hardly unilateral, as the United States recognized many of them including the Paracels and Scarborough during the Potsdam Declaration, Cairo Declaration, San Fransisco Treaty and others (at the time motivated to punish the imperial Japanese at the end of WWII).

Hell the Cairo Declaration even declared Manchuria and Taiwan as owned by China.

It's funny what the American media bubble does to history.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:57PM (#13195222)
For the person/persons downvoting this, can you explain how it does not contribute to the conversation? I'm being very factual and on topic.

If you'd like, we can go over the text of UNCLOS, Cairo and Potsdam Declarations and SF Treaty.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by elefanten on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:04PM (#13195278)
Could you actually elaborate a bit more about how any of those pertain to the Spratly Islands or waters 100 miles off the coast of the Phillipines?

I'm genuinely asking, because my light familiarity with those documents is not sparking a connection.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:24PM (#13195427)
Sure. During WWII the Japanese occupied Pacific Islands including the Paracels and Spratlys.

At the time it came to resolve the war, Japan was forced to remove itself from various occupied areas including but not limited to Korea, China, and Pacific Islands.

For instance in the Cairo Declaration it was stated that:

"Japan shall be stripped of all the islands in the Pacific which she has seized or occupied since the beginning of the first World War in 1914, and that all the territories Japan has stolen from the Chinese, such as Manchuria, Formosa, and The Pescadores, shall be restored to the Republic of China. Japan will also be expelled from all other territories which she has taken by violence and greed. The aforesaid three great powers, mindful of the enslavement of the people of Korea, are determined that in due course Korea shall become free and independent."

Note that here the United States, Britain and China together recognized Manchuria, Taiwan and the islands off of Taiwan as Chinese. Japan would need to extricate itself from Korea.

The Qing Dynasty, before the war, had explored and occupied the Paracels and the Spratlys - to a minimal degree, since it had never become a great naval power. Indeed, there are a number of instances of Vietnam and China 'trading' the Paracels back and forth to protect their ownership during the occupation of French Indochina.

These islands had also been occupied by imperial Japan (such islands are useful in naval warfare), who was forced to remove itself. The Potsdam Declaration reads "Japanese sovereignty shall be limited to the islands of Honshu, Hokkaido, Kyushu, Shikoku and such minor islands as we determine." These islands were very limited indeed, did not include the Paracels/Spratlys and it should be noted that they do not include the Kurils (something today that the Americans would like to revise history on).

Similarly, section (f) of article 2 of the Potsdam Treaty reads of Japan: "Japan renounces all right, title and claim to the Spratly Islands and to the Paracel Islands."

What we have is a situation where the Philippines never had administration or territorial claims to these islands and where the Qing Dynasty had. In the post-war period, China was not only weak, but could not spend much patrolling the South China Sea - and focused primarily on it's Western Front during the Cold War.

Today, China is trying to build infrastructure, shipping routes and naval security in this area. This is important to China because of its historical vulnerability to naval embargo, through the Strait of Malacca and elsewhere.

The United States had hoped, because of weak territorial enforcement during the postwar period, to make an issue over the ownership of the islands and waters as part of a geopolitical effort to limit the expansion of Chinese influence in an area historically militarily dominated by US projection (it's own National Security concerns pertaining to its continued naval access to potential adversaries and compeditors).

The bulwark of that effort was an attempt to build an Asian consensus, centered around the Philippines (an important US ally and prior colony). However, the effort failed, with states in Asia fracturing in opinion and not willing to commit themselves to a United States led effort to persist its power projection in that way.

This is still evolving of course, but the future looks rather dim with the Philippines (the keystone of the project) backing away.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by majormajor on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:35PM (#13195530)
> Note that here the United States, Britain and China together recognized Manchuria, Taiwan and the islands off of Taiwan as Chinese. Japan would need to extricate itself from Korea.

Doesn't this ignore a long-running civil war around the same time that has some relevance to Taiwan's situation? Namely, which Chinese government was Japan giving Taiwan back too?

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:40PM (#13195569)
Yes absolutely the Taiwanese situation is complicated by inter-Chinese conflict.

The official US position (shared by most of the world) is that Taiwan is Chinese territory. The settlement on that issue is that Taiwan will be fully and formally enveloped into the mainland, along with Hong Kong, the 2040s (IIRC). The US (and most of the world) does not recognize Taiwan as an independent sovereignty. Think Puerto Rico.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by majormajor on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:49PM (#13195663)
Yes, but my point was that this wasn't all some simple thing going back to a post-WWII treaty that was now being complicated by a US imperialist media bubble. The current official position came about decades later and is additionally complicated by the unofficial relations between the US and the two being quite different.

On a completely not-realpolitik-based personal side of things, having spent some time in all three of China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan, a forced eventual unification feels rather sad if it comes with the greater globalized monoculture that the mainland currently has.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:05PM (#13195791)
All treaties, settlements and borders are subject to be changed. It's simply a fact.

It is entirely possible that, in a war or as a settlement, or under pressure, or by sale/trade, or by volunteer Russia will give the Kurils to Japan, or the United States will revise its position on Taiwan or Hong Kong (you've already see a Trump Administration send the signal he's willing to do this).

These relations are complicated, as various decisions made by different sovereignties will be replied to, can spoil relationships, can spoil trust, etc.

A nation can also ruin its reputation by being 'too flippant' in recognizing territory until its not convenient to do so any more. There's a giant fuzzy 'you-have-to-be-able-to-tell-the-future' calculus that is done in simulating various choices on how to proceed with sovereign decisions, as effects can be quite wide ranging.

America flipping its opinion on the sovereignty of the former British colony Hong Kong or on the civil war safehaven Taiwan, would represent a huge and damaging departure in relations with China. The United States may do such a thing, but would only do it if the 'realpolitik' calculus allowed it to risk - or wanted it to aggress - a war.

There's never a simple thing in geopolitics. We can only look to history, to policies and treaties and to potential outcomes to explain and predict. The United States breaking with long standing treaties would be huge news in this regard.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by majormajor on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:19PM (#13195916)
> There's never a simple thing in geopolitics. We can only look to history, to policies and treaties and to potential outcomes to explain and predict.

So doesn't this bring us to "it's news that China has started treating these waters differently" for objective reasons vs it only being an "American media bubble" thing?

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:37PM (#13196077)
Yes. I hope I did that.

China is treating these waters differently today for National Security reasons, and because of a unique period of history in which Chinese growth and infrastructure development has skyrocketed (China has been successfully industrializing into a modern economy). I had said: "Today, China is trying to build infrastructure, shipping routes and naval security in this area. This is important to China because of its historical vulnerability to naval embargo, through the Strait of Malacca and elsewhere."

The American media bubble is the narrative that China is being aggressive, that China is being unilateral, that China has no claims (especially vis a vis Philippines), that there is a unanimous interpretation in Asia, etc.

The media bubble in this regard isn't "something has changed" but "this is what's changed and this is what's going on."

It's a nice story about good versus evil and American freedom, sure, but that's only good for headlines and public consumption. It's not what is going to fill the history books.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by lacampbell on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:15PM (#13196917)
> The official US position (shared by most of the world) is that Taiwan is Chinese territory.

Citation? It helps to be clear when you use "Chinese" in this context. It is certainly not the US position that Taiwan is PRC territory. They are deliberately ambiguous on this.

> The settlement on that issue is that Taiwan will be fully and formally enveloped into the mainland, along with Hong Kong, the 2040s (IIRC).

First I've heard of this settlement. Again, citations?

> The US (and most of the world) does not recognize Taiwan as an independent sovereignty. Think Puerto Rico.

Puerto Rico does is not de jure independent and does not claim to be. Completely different. The ROC is de facto independent.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:07PM (#13197334)
> The official US position...

The termination of the Sino-American Mutual Defense Treaty ("SAMSG") and the passage of the Taiwan Relations Act ("TRA"). In the "SAMDT" it was the policy of the United States that the Republic of China (ROC - Taiwan) was the sole legitimate sovereignty of mainland China.

President Carter terminated SAMDT, passing instead the TRA. The Taiwan Relations Act promotes a "One China Policy" - that of there being only one China. Under this policy, the US government recognizes the PRC (mainland) government, and no longer recognizes Taiwan (ROC) as a sovereignty. In this, there is no formal recognition, state-to-state diplomacy at high levels, present embassy, etc. The TRA makes provisions for the defense of the island in the case of military activity from the mainland. The TRA has been consistently reaffirmed by the United States government for 40 years.

> The settlement on that issue is that Taiwan will be fully and formally enveloped into the mainland, along with Hong Kong, the 2040s.

I have overspoken and confused the Hong Kong case with the Taiwan case. To be very clear: I am and was wrong about the timeline on a formal date for the mainland to envelop Taiwan.

The "Basic Law" of the Constitution of Hong Kong that establishes it as a separate autonomous region expires in (I had to look this up) 1947. This arrangement had been agreed to by the British and the mainland Chinese government, with the understanding the independence would cede after this time.

I had been under the impression that Taiwan had a similar provision in their constitution. However, looking this up I found that it is not the case. ROC and PRC both agree that there is "One China" as does the United States, but there remains disagreement about where the sovereignty resides. A good example of this is that ROC sided entirely with PRC with regard to the South China Sea and the international disputes and findings.

There does not appear to be a deadline on the federalization of the relationship, and I sincerely apologize that I stated this incorrectly.

Now, I do swear to have heard US diplomats and academics discussing the Hong Kong and Taiwan timeframe as a single event: "One Country, Three Systems." I have nothing formal or official to point to in this regard.

> Think Puerto Rico

There are many differences between the two cases and it was not intended to to be taken beyond the most immediate analogy. The US, as by the TRA, does not recognize the sovereignty of Taiwan as an independent sovereignty. I was trying to come up with something American readers might be able to compare that to. PR probably came to mind because it too is an island, and it too is not recognized as a sovereign state. Of course the analogy is not perfect and I would never claim it is.

Thank you for clarifying that to other readers.

There is not a strong constituency of Puerto Rico that claims independent sovereignty. I don't know if they are actively seeking political representation of any sort (as a US state?). There isn't actually much news/information (that I get anyway) about the political climate on PR.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by dragonwriter on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:13PM (#13197372)
> Now, I do swear to have heard US diplomats and academics discussing the Hong Kong and Taiwan timeframe as a single event: "One Country, Three Systems." I have nothing formal or official to point to in this regard.

It's definitely something people talk about sometimes as a potential (or for some even predicted) outcome, but it's mostly speculative with little firm basis in general, and even less in terms of any specific time frame.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by lacampbell on Saturday December 17, 2016 @02:14AM (#13199711)
The US has only ever "acknowledged" that the PRC considers Taiwan a part of its territory. The fact that diplomatic recognition has switched to the PRC does not imply that the US believes Taiwan is part of the PRC. It's deliberately ambiguous on all of this.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by lacampbell on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:06PM (#13196843)
It is their purpose that Japan shall be stripped of all the islands in the Pacific which she has seized or occupied since the beginning of the first World War in 1914, and that all the territories Japan has stolen from the Chinese, such as Manchuria, Formosa, and The Pescadores, shall be restored to the Republic of China.

And Formosa and the Pescadores are today governed by the by the Republic of China, at least.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by EliRivers on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:58PM (#13195236)
It seems that the Vietnamese media bubble does the same, then. As does the Philippine media bubble, the Malay media bubble, the Brunei media bubble, and everyone else in the region who has just watched China annex the ocean off their shore.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:05PM (#13195286)
This is a mischaracterization of the Vietnamese press, Malay press, Philippine press, etc. I've seen plenty of articles criticizing the Philippine and US behavior in the South China Sea from these countries, and indeed the Philippines has for the most part stopped pressing their claim.

Mostly, Japan and the United States don't want it to happen. You'll see their bubble selectively translate and report on Thai, Vietnamese, etc press. I'm sorry you seem to be under the impression there's such a uniform voice.

The United States had hoped to build a uniform front and accusation against China, with the Philippines at the center.

That effort failed. And it's getting to be nearly a year.

In any case, you seem to take exception with the 'bubble accusation'. We can talk about that, if you like, but I would be interested in talking about the various declarations and treaties at the end of WWII.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by EliRivers on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:03PM (#13197296)
I'm sorry you seem to be under the impression there's such a uniform voice.

I think you're lying. I don't think you're sorry. I think this is childish, passive-aggressive bullshit from someone who knows how to act like an adult but somehow can't resist acting like a child. Here's how a grown man states what you were trying to say; "There's not such a uniform voice as you think across the different nations you mentioned." For God's sake, grow up. You seem to have some actual facts to present, but a childish tone undermines everything.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by jwtadvice on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:24PM (#13197444)
Here is a source, dated in the May of this year, in which policy wonks (Julian Ku, Fravel, Malcohm Cook) discuss the situation in the South China Sea and United States Freedom of Navigation Operations ("FONOPs").

http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/05/16/freedom-of-navigation-op...

This isn't an outlier in reporting on the situation in the South China Sea: reporting - and the diplomacy - emphasizes the need for the United States to find allies and to build a consensus of Asian countries.

The response from those would-be-allied Asian countries, the policy wonks discuss, has been ambivilent at best. They link to an article in which the Indonesian government criticizes the US for power projection and calls on the US and China to 'restrain themselves'. The Indonesian response in this regard was not an outlier.

Much of the advice to US diplomats was that the FONOPs needed to be changed because the aggressive nature of the military projection undercut the narrative that China was the bully. Advice on changing the operations included doing them silently without much public coverage, or trying to build a coalition so that the US wouldn't 'sail alone'. (The US was unable to build such a coalition.)

There's a lot to say in this regard.

I think your comment(s) are highly constructive, I take seriously what you say, and have been upvoting them.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by dang on Saturday December 17, 2016 @10:02PM (#13204081)
You've been using HN for pure politics for quite a while now. That's an abuse of this site, and we ban accounts that do it. Please stop.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by eternalban on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:08PM (#13195309)
The power calculus isn't all that different from the one that requires American dominance at sea, worldwide. In both cases, a power (one global, one local) is asserting control over strategic assets and ultimately arguing that the arrangement promotes stability and is better in the long run for the little fishies involved.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by Altay- on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:44PM (#13195609)
Who says its 'international waters'? The Western created UN shackle? Fact is America is operating thousands of miles away from its territory. The only reason to do that is hostility and Imperialism.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by Brockenstein on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:59PM (#13195747)
China is on the UN and one of the permanent members of the security council...

If China doesn't want to play by the rules everyone else has agreed to, they can go become a bigger version of North Korea.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by linkregister on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:00PM (#13195753)
Agreed, why is the U.S. standing in the way of righteous Chinese Navy sailors from claiming their birthright territorial waters of the Philippines, Vietnam, Korea, and Chinese Taipei (Taiwan is a fiction spun by pig-dog imperialist American spies).
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by nullnilvoid on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:15PM (#13195357)
The drones were clearly, undisputedly trying to spy on China. That is a blatantly provocative move. If Russia sends drones near the coast of new york city in the international waters, do you think the US will open arms and welcome them?
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by woofyman on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:25PM (#13195449)
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by bduerst on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:31PM (#13195492)
Yes.

Russia and the U.S. are members of the Open Skies treaty, meaning we already allow unarmed observation over each other's land as part of building confidence with each other.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by MrZongle2 on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:25PM (#13195444)
The Chinese and Russians have spy satellites that pass over the United States.

Does that justify the United States destroying, de-orbiting, or otherwise taking them?

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by EliRivers on Friday December 16, 2016 @04:59PM (#13197266)
clearly, undisputedly trying to spy on China

Get a map. Look at where the drone was taken. See how far away from China it was.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by woofyman on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:48PM (#13195142)
It was a submersible in international waters.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by rz2k on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:44PM (#13195104)
Ugh, I really hope no one decides that sort of idea gives them license to take Russian equipment operating in Carribean international waters.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by sleepingeights on Friday December 16, 2016 @05:07PM (#13197330)
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by EliRivers on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:55PM (#13195201)
The name of the sea having the word "China" in it doesn't actually make it Chinese territorial waters.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by vkou on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:00PM (#13195259)
No, but how would the US react to China doing the same in international waters right off the coast of San Francisco?
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by mc32 on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:06PM (#13195297)
When you say right off the coast you mean hundreds of miles from the mainland coast? I think the US is fine with foreign vessels operating in international waters.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by 67726e on Friday December 16, 2016 @03:45PM (#13196625)
In fact making sure international waters are navigable is a bit of a priority for us.
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by anigbrowl on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:03PM (#13195773)
Like this for example (OK it's Hawai'i rather than SF but that's still US territory)?

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/chinese-spy-ship-sp...

Look, this sort of thing (observing each other from a safe distance) takes place all the time. We're fine with the Chinese ship shadowing the US one, watching us watching them, and we do the same thing in reverse. That's how naval powers have carried on business for centuries. It's like poker players looking at how many chips their opponents have on the table in order to guess at their strategy on the next hand. You can lok all you want, but you can't reach over and help yourself to one of the other players' chips.

Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by mr_spothawk on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:42PM (#13195089)
they were doing what drones everywhere do... "measuring" with "sensors".
Re:Chinese warship stole US underwater drone by ipnon on Friday December 16, 2016 @12:50PM (#13195153)
Here's your 50 cents.