Re:Rust required to build Gecko
by Manishearth on Friday December 16, 2016 @01:34AM
(#13191503)
Please explain why you think this is of value. To me it seems like an explicit vs implicit thing; and I can easily imagine people not wanting their build step to magically touch their system setup. I have a pretty custom Rust setup, I would not be happy if Firefox would silently change that every time I built things.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It wouldn't touch their system setup--that's the point.
You get reproducible builds because the build happens in its own sandbox, ideally. But it's not absolute.
There's a continuum here: it's not awesome to have builds from source for every library if you know you're building inside a defined Docker image, for example.
Re:Rust required to build Gecko
by Manishearth on Friday December 16, 2016 @02:07AM
(#13191612)
Yeah, that sounds useful. However, I would caution against making such a thing the default since it would bloat the space it takes on disk. In the past when I was a student with a crappy laptop I never worked on Chrome because it just took too much disk space to build and I didn't have enough. Not sure if it's because it built all dependencies locally instead of relying on the OS or something else.
So yeah, would be nice to have, but I'd be wary about making it the default.