How does assuming that macros don't scale help in proving that macros don't scale?
How does the complexity of C++ templates prove anything about syntactic abstraction in general or Lisp macros in particular?
Re:C++ vs. Lisp
by MichaelSalib on Tuesday May 04, 2010 @07:05PM
(#1319732)
C++ templates are both less powerful and more complex and fragile than lisp macros. But no one ever says "oh, the C++ templating system does not scale" or "oh, C++ will never be successful until it eliminates/replaces the templating system"...do they?
Or, to put it another way: lots of C++ shops ban the use of advanced templating metaprogramming. Has C++ suffered egregiously as a result?