Re:Psychiatrists Must Face Possibility That Medications Hurt...
by jobu on Thursday December 15, 2016 @02:45PM
(#13187576)
Have you tried Alpha-GPC? Some people say it works better than CDP Choline, but it seems to be very situational.
Lately I've had more issues with staying focused and refocusing after distractions and I've started looking into nootropics. Unfortunately they seem to affect everyone differently.
Re:Psychiatrists Must Face Possibility That Medications Hurt...
by pmoriarty on Thursday December 15, 2016 @03:43PM
(#13188207)
I have not tried Alpha-GPC, but I am aware that it is similar to CDP Choline. From my own reading of the many comparisons of the two, CDP Choline is supposed to be the more effective, safer, and cheaper one. I might try Alpha-GPC at some point, but right now I'm pretty happy with CDP Choline.
I'm not super gung ho on experimenting with nootropics in general, and try to be very conservative and err on the side of caution. There are all sorts of different nootropics out there that sound really cool, but I'm just not very much in to using myself as a guinea pig for them. So I don't try a lot, and when I do I go for ones that are known to be super safe and widely used.
Re:Psychiatrists Must Face Possibility That Medications Hurt...
by noir_lord on Thursday December 15, 2016 @02:48PM
(#13187608)
My experience with diet exactly matches yours, due to health problems I had to start eating the fodmap diet, improvement in mental state and focus was incredible, I felt like I was back in my twenties again.
Re:Psychiatrists Must Face Possibility That Medications Hurt...
by komali2 on Thursday December 15, 2016 @01:43PM
(#13186987)
I genuinely appreciate your advice, and I always like to investigate alternatives to Adderall. That being said, I've been tackling ADHD and depression from multiple angles for a couple decades now, and luckily that resulted in me finding I'm happier when I eat well and exercise (so I keep doing it), but in the end the medication is what it takes to allow me to perform alongside my colleagues.
I then started taking DHA and CDP Choline, and all of the above symptoms went away. I was back to "normal". Through experimentation with stopping and restarting both DHA and CDP Choline, I figured out that it was the latter which was responsible for the change. There were days when I'd forget to take the CDP Choline and then later in the day notice that I felt I had trouble focusing and then realised, "oh yeah, I forgot to take the CDP". Starting to take it again would relieve the symptoms. This happened more than once. I also went for months without taking either supplement, where I'd run out and procrastinate on getting a refill, and sure enough, I'd go back to having trouble concentrating. Then I'd finally get a refill of CDP and I'd be able to focus well again. All of this has convinced me that CDP really is working for me.
Later, due to some other health issues (not related to cognition) that I've had, I took a good hard look at my diet, and found out that many health issues that I have and have had in the past could very likely be due to various vitamin and mineral deficiencies. Though I've always known that my diet wasn't really healthy, I never realized how much of a profound effect the lack of proper vitamins and minerals could have on my mental and physical health.
I started eating a lot more healthily (in particular, eating lots of fruits and vegetables, which were almost completely missing from my diet in the past), and taking supplements for some of the nutrients which I was still not getting adequate amounts of from my diet.
As a result, I feel much better, have a ton more energy, feel in a better mood, and have no problems concentrating.
I strongly encourage you to take a hard look at your diet to see if you're missing or low on any essential nutrients, and consider supplementing those (or, better yet, getting them through eating more nutritious food). It can really make a world of difference.