If you want to learn a language for the express purpose of expanding your mind, try a postfix language like Forth or Joy. Those are different enough from what you've done so far that it'll be pretty strange to think in that manner at first. I haven't pursued either Forth or Joy beyond messing around with a couple toy examples, but they're very interesting to think about.
I'm finding Lua/Terra quite interesting. Lua [1] is an extremely lightweight fast dynamic-typed interpreted (or JIT-compiled) language (don't forget to get the penlight library, though, because it's batteries-not-included otherwise). Terra [2] is a C-level bare-metal static-typed compiled language specifically designed both to use Lua as a preprocessor and to interleave with Lua code as necessary. I'm pretty sure it ends up as metaprogrammable as Lisp but without the difficulty I had parsing Lisp syntax (might not be an issue for you, given that you've got Scheme listed).
[1][http://www.lua.org/] [2][http://terralang.org/]
Again, though - unless you need it tiny, you probably want Penlight or something like it to provide all the utilities that weren't quite basic enough to be core. In that case, you've got a good chunk of, effectively, the Python core libraries to work with.
I think OP missed entirely the point of learning a new language. When I learn a new language, I try to use the language the way it was built to be used, instead of trying to adapt it to what I already know. That's why you'll often see me asking questions like: "What is the Rubyist way to solve this?". I do adapt the language, but only after I've tried their way first.
I started programming by learning C, which taught me how the computer 'thinks'. Oh, and the absolute basics of programming.
I learned C++, where I was firstly introduced to objects and reliable ways do handle resource allocations without leaks (hopefully :).
I learned Ruby, where I was firstly introduced to functional programming and a wonderful implementation of the language using objects. I also learned what expressive your code can be.
I learned JavaScript, which didn't teach me much, but I've used it extensively to practice what I had learned before. JavaScript does everything.
I learned Haskell, which taught me more functional programming, and how problems go away when you use the correct types (or containers).
I learned Scheme, which showed me how simple a language's syntax can be, while still effective. It confirmed what I knew all along: all those different syntaxes mostly don't matter.
Sure I could have learned all those things without learning a new language. But I had no idea they even existed. Now, what will I learn next? Any suggestions?