Re:Running as a Thinking Person’s Sport
by hueving on Thursday December 15, 2016 @09:35AM
(#13184769)
VO2max has nothing to do with joints. Your post is all over the place.
Re:Running as a Thinking Person’s Sport
by notacoward on Thursday December 15, 2016 @10:07AM
(#13185037)
No, my post is not all over the place. You're just not very good at reading. Effect on joints was the OP's point 1. Effect on fitness was point 3. Must I address those points in separate replies, even though they were made in one? That's absurd. Also, they're not completely unrelated and I've even drawn the lines between them. Talk of running's negatives should be balanced by consideration of its positives. Even if running is harmful to the joints, and already cited evidence suggests otherwise, that might still be outweighed by the aerobic benefits. More people die of heart attacks than of sore knees. I don't think it's unreasonable to counter unremittingly negative commentary with some mention of positives.
Next time, try reading what others write, instead of cherry-picking one piece out of context to address in support of your biases.
Re:Running as a Thinking Person’s Sport
by hueving on Thursday December 15, 2016 @08:10PM
(#13190271)
>You're just not very good at reading.
Now this is what this site is about.
Unless you are intentionally trolling, I recommend you remove personal attacks from your discourse if you want to engage in any kind of intelligent conversation.
Re:Running as a Thinking Person’s Sport
by notacoward on Tuesday December 20, 2016 @03:58PM
(#13223887)
So a one-line comment that's nothing but cherry-picking/diversion is OK, but calling you on it - and also continuing the actual discussion with facts and stuff - is a mortal sin? Look at all the responses in this thread. It's pretty clear that I did a pretty good job spurring an intelligent conversation, and you didn't, so I contend that your criteria/priorities are way out of whack.
As for the other part of your comment, when I mentioned swimming etc. in the context of overall benefit, not harm to joints. I've yet to see evidence that cycling is easier on the joints, and I've seen plenty that it's slightly below running in terms of aerobic benefit. Sure, an elite cyclist probably has a higher VO2max than I do, but if we compare apples to apples then we'd have to compare to an elite marathon runner and I don't think that comparison would look so good.