News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RFC 7764 – Guidance on Markdown by c-smile on Thursday December 15, 2016 @12:40AM (#13182705)
"Oh how many of them had fallen into that chasm..." (C) M. Tsvetaeva

Instead of markdown we need something what I name as flat structural text format.

     <text>Base level text</text>
     <text li="disk">Bulleted list item</text>
     <text li="numeric">Numeric list item</text>
     <text li="numeric" level=2>Another list item</text>
     ...
     <text>Inline <span bold>bold</span><span bold italic>bold and italic</span></text>   
     ...
In this case it will be trivial[1] to write WYSIWYG editor that has 1:1 mapping between markup and screen representation.

That 1:1 mapping is mission critical for human editing - our mental model of text is flat.

In fact that markdown is an attempt to provide such flat structural text representation. Ugly one we shall admit.

Microsoft Word, AFAIU, uses also flat DOM model internally, that's why its WYSIWYG is quite good.

HTML version 2 was last version that allowed unambiguous WYSIWYG editing of HTML. The one that had no idea of CSS.

[1] http://blocknote.net - WYSIWYG HTML editor that uses internal flat model.

Re:RFC 7764 – Guidance on Markdown by crooked-v on Thursday December 15, 2016 @02:44AM (#13183121)
This entirely misses the point of Markdown: that it's completely readable as a document without needing to apply any kind of visual formatting to it.
Re:RFC 7764 – Guidance on Markdown by c-smile on Thursday December 15, 2016 @01:27PM (#13186842)
> completely readable ...

That's very subjective and only in very simple cases. Like "markdown" version here, on HN.