News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by kem on Thursday December 15, 2016 @12:13AM (#13182609)
I had a rejected journal submission show up again as a keynote conference presentation a couple of years later. To be fair, with that sort of thing we could have just had the exact same ideas and so forth, but it wasn't a common research topic, and there were suggestive dots easy enough to connect. Regardless, it raised all sorts of alarms about what might have actually happened, and I started thinking seriously about the value of non-peer-reviewed, completely open publishing just as a way of maintaining authorship credit. Even if everything were totally innocent, it was a bit unnerving about the attribution of ideas and everything.

I'm having major conflicts about academics as a career. It seems to get more and more insane every day.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by rebuilder on Thursday December 15, 2016 @06:23AM (#13183842)
So proof of original authorship is a big issue in academia? You could easily create timestamped proof of having created a particular document, so is the issue more an insitutional one? Pardon me if I make sense, I'm a complete outsider to this.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by ldjb on Thursday December 15, 2016 @06:53AM (#13183960)
That would rely on everybody creating timestamped proof, otherwise you could claim ownership of any paper that hasn't been timestamped by timestamping it yourself.

Not all cases are clear-cut, especially where a plagiariser restructures the document, changes the wording, sources, etc..

So I don't think this is a problem that can be solved practically, or even theoretically. But there are certainly things that can be done to better counter plagiarism.

Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by whiteandnerdy on Saturday December 17, 2016 @07:21AM (#13200446)
You could post a hash of the paper to a trusted host like Twitter at the point you submit it, and you could then refer to that for proof of authorship and priority at a future date.
Re:Letter to a Peer Reviewer Who Stole and Published Our Man... by ldjb on Saturday December 17, 2016 @03:08PM (#13202242)
You could, however what happens if an author does not post a hash? If I found someone else's paper without a hash, I could generate a hash of my own and claim authorship.

This idea would only work if everybody started securing some form of proof of authorship before sharing papers with anyone, which I don't quite see happening.