Note that neither of these authors argue that the scientific method is wrong (as some new-agey types do), but rather that it is incomplete, and a poor tool for understanding the real world in many situations.
What classical world do you refer to? Newtonian physics? That's well understood, the general area of study is called thermal physics.
Are you talking about how the brain works? The biologists understand the meso-scale structures and the microscale structures, and the wiring. What they lack is a certified, detailed diagram, which is admittedly hard, but it's hard like understanding the wiring diagram of an ARM chip is hard.
I don't agree at all. Thermal (classical) physics may be consistent with quantum physics but this does not at all show how a classical world arises from the quantum.
Why? They have been completely successful. The reduction from QM to newtonian mechanics is very easy; you just turn the action way up so that you can't see the quantization gaps between actions anymore.
QM is not acausal. Even in QFT where we have interactions that look time-reversed, they still aren't acausal.
This is just not true. For example when enanglement is involved all of this goes out the window. Indeed, the next few decades of quantum computing is going to be completely non-reducible to newtownian mechanics.
> QM is not acausal.
I disagree entirely. QM is exactly acausal. Also known as the measurement problem.
Fair enough, this is sort of a counter example to the "increase the action" trick, but it does work for any local effects.
> Also known as the measurement problem.
There is no need to violate causality to solve the measurement problem. Even superluminal solutions don't allow for the superluminal transmission of information, so causality is preserved. There are huge families of solutions that don't require superluminality at all (einselection, many worlds, etc.).
I'm not suggesting to violate causality, I'm saying there just is no cause.
> to solve the measurement problem
I don't think there is any solution. The physical laws of the universe are incomplete, they do not determine what "happens." There are constraints in the form of probabilities, so it's not like anything can happen at any time. But what actually happens, it's spontaneous, un-caused.
> huge families of solutions
This is a vast area of research that has spanned decades and yielded very little in the way of solutions. Hence my use of the term "boneheaded" above.
Ah, your problem is that you only seem to be aware of the Copenhagen interpretation. There are other interpretations available that work just as well, but don't have anything as inconvenient as nondeterminism.
> This is a vast area of research that has spanned decades and yielded very little in the way of solutions.
No, you are wrong here.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_interpretation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einselection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Objective_collapse_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transactional_interpretation
Yes, what were these?
I tend to agree with you about causality. The attempts to understand how the classical world arises from quantum laws seem particularly boneheaded to me. I guess people (scientists) don't want to let go of causality because who knows what chaos and mayhem will befall the world if we give up on this. And the philosophers have a term "causal closure" which seems to be axiomatic in alot of their discussions. But they just don't want to talk about any kind of mystical stuff that might seep in through the gaps.