News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's Wrong with Literary Studies? by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @01:13PM (#13169000)
This whole critique mindset is kind of a self-inflicted wound on literary studies. If you destroy the ability of literature to say what the author intended it to say. This hurts literary studies for two reasons:

1. It takes what is great about literature and replaces it with something less. Hamlet is better than any of the critiques or deconstructions of Hamlet. It's better than any of the criticism of Hamlet, too, but the new approach is worse. The old criticism tried to show how the work could have been written better; the new critique tries to make you try to ignore the author's point.

2. The critique approach destroys itself. If one applied the techniques of literary critique to any literary critique, what would survive? Almost nothing - certainly not the author's point.

Then why bother doing literary studies, if we're going to ignore what the authors are trying to say, and if we can also ignore what the papers published in literary studies say? What's the point? Why bother with the whole exercise?

[Edit: I read further, and...

> "Today’s anti-pedophile," Ruddick writes, summarizing the analysis, "perpetrates the ‘potential violence’ of ‘speaking on [children’s] behalf.’ " Such ideas violate scholars’ private convictions, Ruddick says, but they go unchallenged because they seem to mesh with the ideology of the group.

I try to avoid profanity, but: What the hell is wrong with these people? They see speaking on a child's behalf as "potential violence", but ignore the real violence that pedophilia does to the child? And that viewpoint meshes with the ideology of the literary studies establishment?

Words fail me. This is appalling.

Now, at least, "such ideas violate scholars' private convictions". Thank God for that much. But if they don't dare go against the seeming ideology of the group, which seems to be the ideology of the group because nobody else dares go against it either, that's getting pretty close to "systemic evil".]

There are no comments on this comment yet.