Re:Prolific Engineers Take Small Bites
by minimaxir on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @11:47AM
(#13168194)
You don't have to expose the raw dataset explicitly, but you do need to describe your methodology (moreso than an arbitrary "impact" score; give a formula) and give actual numbers for the analysis, and not just argue a "strong correlation" with a highly arbitrary matrix of attributes.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Prolific Engineers Take Small Bites
by arethuza on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @11:55AM
(#13168271)
It's a marketing article - trying to explain their product to potential customers, not a scientific publication.
I'm not saying that you are necessarily wrong but I do wonder if making an article like this more like a formal publication will actually make it better or worse at it's real goal which is presumably to sell more.
Re:Prolific Engineers Take Small Bites
by minimaxir on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @12:01PM
(#13168324)
Yes, the standards of an marketing article are nonacademic, but you can't make a article containing a data driven argument and skimp on both the data and the argument.
Re:Prolific Engineers Take Small Bites
by mannykannot on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @10:25PM
(#13173540)
There is no downside to a legitimate marketing article to make the underlying data and analysis available to those who want to drill down. If it is valid, you stand a chance of persuading the skeptics.
More importantly, calling something a marketing article does not immunize it from critical analysis, and especially not on a forum such as HN.
I don't know if it's respectable to doll up a marketing article like journalism, let alone scientific research.
Re:Prolific Engineers Take Small Bites
by jabagonuts on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @12:09PM
(#13168387)
They go into slightly more detail on factors that influence the impact rating in a linked post. It still doesn't explain what formula or weightings they use. https://blog.gitprime.com/impact-a-better-way-to-measure-cod...