"I live in San Francisco and I have no problems at all with my Macs" sounds like an explanation of all the problems with the Mac.
And a +1 here. Would just add that we also need to look at the offer of product lines that Apple provides to better understand their decisions.
Also, IMO, people are becoming more and more desensitised, always expecting big leaps in innovation and specs and not noticing the small steps, cornerstones of the vision Apple has for its user's experience.
There is a super-serious case of rose-tinted glasses going on here. I think you're right - this is just the herd trying to decide which new opinion to coalesce around.
iCloud Photo Library works and works reliably for me every day. Apple Maps has much higher resolution satellite photos of SF than Google Maps and its transit directions are superior, giving specific exit numbers. The new MBP has a wicket fast storage subsystem, something that will make far more difference to far more people than a hypothetical 32GB of RAM.
I don't buy the doom and gloom.