Re:Identify dog by image
by dbg31415 on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @09:01AM
(#13166772)
I've updated the gallery with some more pictures. On the whole... my opinion stands. The tool stinks.
But really it's setting out to do something stupid. Dogs are just dogs, this concept of breed... it's not a great way to identify them.
We took some wolves, bred them down to get gentle and obedient pets... then started getting silly about wanting dogs that were tiny or dogs that were big or dogs with brown spots... and really that's all the "breeds" are is us saying, "That's a dog with a red nose and pointy ears."
But once that dog has puppies with another dog, say one with brown nose and floppy ears, the puppies are anyone's guess. They're back to just being domesticated wolves again -- mutts.
My "Cattle Dog" is way too small, she's mixed with something else. She's only 30 pounds... The DNA test said that my "Pointer" was "Pit Bull" and "Grey Hound" -- which, if you accept "Pit Bull" as a breed, is roughly what "Pointers" were made from -- and the tool sort of got some of the traits right.
Re:Identify dog by image
by ry_ry on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @03:23AM
(#13165373)
Running off the cognative services APIs I guess?
Already well-known, but for anybody who hasn't seen them and is interested in playing with this sort of thing on the cheap, Microsoft have free (rate limited) rest APIs available if you want to have a mooch...
Re:Identify dog by image
by nailer on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @07:33AM
(#13166305)
Tried with Lierre the Borzoi https://www.instagram.com/zoifeathers . Incorrectly guessed Golden Retriever, probably based on the fur length. Skull length should be taken into account to help guess sighthounds.
* Bad Dog Match - Album on Imgur || http://imgur.com/a/v8jin
Only got 1 picture right... (but it couldn't identify this same dog in other pictures).
* Imgur: The most awesome images on the Internet || http://imgur.com/C4dXSfj
But really it's setting out to do something stupid. Dogs are just dogs, this concept of breed... it's not a great way to identify them.
We took some wolves, bred them down to get gentle and obedient pets... then started getting silly about wanting dogs that were tiny or dogs that were big or dogs with brown spots... and really that's all the "breeds" are is us saying, "That's a dog with a red nose and pointy ears."
But once that dog has puppies with another dog, say one with brown nose and floppy ears, the puppies are anyone's guess. They're back to just being domesticated wolves again -- mutts.
My "Cattle Dog" is way too small, she's mixed with something else. She's only 30 pounds... The DNA test said that my "Pointer" was "Pit Bull" and "Grey Hound" -- which, if you accept "Pit Bull" as a breed, is roughly what "Pointers" were made from -- and the tool sort of got some of the traits right.
Correct -
http://imgur.com/C4dXSfj
http://imgur.com/e7KkUTk
http://imgur.com/8YTVFnd - ish
http://imgur.com/iUOYWP8 - ish
Just humorously bad -
http://imgur.com/CTJhpZx
http://imgur.com/Tep32aA (relative size of dog in shot = chihuahua)
http://imgur.com/ItkWja4
http://imgur.com/dHIJJDl
http://imgur.com/yMxCoyR
Already well-known, but for anybody who hasn't seen them and is interested in playing with this sort of thing on the cheap, Microsoft have free (rate limited) rest APIs available if you want to have a mooch...
https://www.microsoft.com/cognitive-services/en-us/apis
I haven't tested it on dogs, but it is fun to use on human faces with kids (might be fun at parties, too)