News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Animats on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:51PM (#13161288)
As someone else pointed out, this is a long, detailed critique of Wikipedia by someone whose main objection is that "by 2007 the water had become hot enough to be felt by devotees of modern fiction (that is, anime & manga franchises, video games, novels, etc.)" There are legitimate criticisms of Wikipedia, but that it now discourages "fancruft" isn't much of one. There are many other popular culture forums. If you want to write about anime, get an account on MyAnimeList or Daisuki or Wikia. (Daisuki, incidentally, is a project of the Cool Japan Fund, a VC fund to export Japanese culture, funded by the government of Japan and some big banks.) There's Pottermore and Wookiepedia and the Marvel Universe Wiki. There are places for that stuff, and they're big and active.

"Deletionism" is mostly pushback against the incoming tide of promotional articles. Here's an essay I wrote on dealing with conflict of interest editing.[1] Without considerable pushback, Wikipedia would read like PR Newswire. Too often, it still does. As I note in my essay, on Wikipedia, it's not what you have to say about yourself, it's what other reliable sources say about you. Wikipedia is one of the very few resources on the Web that's not choked with advertising and promotion. That's valuable.

Editor retention is a problem. Editing Wikipedia is hard. It's not like writing on a blog or forum. It's like submitting a pull request to a major open source project. It's not difficult for anyone who has published in a refereed journal, but that's under 1% of the population. It's painful for someone who's never had their writing tightly edited. So is submitting code to a successful project. It's one way to get better at writing.

Despite this, Wikipedia is dealing well with the hard problems. As the Trump administration takes power, many articles needed to be updated, and, despite controversies, that process is going reasonably well. The Washington Post comments that, over time, Wikipedia articles on controversial subjects approach a neutral point of view.[2] Few other places on the Web achieve that, or even try.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Hints_on_dealing_wit... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/10/25/somet...

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by clock_tower on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:08PM (#13164361)
Good, someone's making this point!

I'd argue that it's specifically "modern fiction" that made Wikipedia hard to take seriously in the early years (was it that they had a biography of Pikachu but not of Charles XII of Sweden?), and that a hard line on fancruft but lenience in other areas would make sense.

On the other hand, I hadn't known about the PR issue, and I think I now understand why Wikipedia is so unforgiving towards Mittelstand businesses. If the only information you can get about the second-largest sprocket-maker in Topeka was written by the second-largest sproket-maker in Topeka, it might indeed be better to leave them off the site entirely...