News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:29PM (#13160455)
I don't understand how this is a "proxy metric".

I'll give you the shortest defense of deletionism I can write:

There are two problems with non-notable articles in Wikipedia.

The first is definitional. An encyclopedia is a tertiary source: a roadmap and synopsis of existing sources. Non-notable sources are by definition those for which existing reliable sources are absent. All such articles are, in a very simple sense, "original research". One of the most basic founding principles of Wikipedia, as old as NPOV, is "no original research".

The second is pragmatic. Wikipedia is committed to minimizing error. Entropy exerts tremendous force on the project, which occupies extremely valuable Internet real estate. Every article on Wikipedia is in a sense a commitment by the Wikipedia community to mount a defense against bias, advertisement, promotion, vandalism, and basic inaccuracy. The notability requirement, which is at bottom based not on "fame" but on the quality of sources available for a topic, is an extremely reasonable boundary to put on the expectations Wikipedia can have of its unpaid editors to combat that entropy: to wit, that we will do so only when available sources make the job possible to do in the first place.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Tomte on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:21PM (#13160974)
> Wikipedia is committed to minimizing error.

Try to tell that to the guys who feel like they own the /dev/random article on Wiki-DE:

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diskussion:/dev/random#.2Fdev....

An "IP" (which is basically a kind of online racism, because ostensibly "IPs" are not addresses but a certain kind of people) tried to correct the usual /dev/urandom misinformation. It was reverted, called vandalism and the user bakunin finally stated that he reverted because "the discussion was getting on his nerves" and "even if the change was factually correct", it was obviously vandalism.

I know why I don't try to contribute to Wikipedia. When the half-time of donations to the project can be measured in minutes, it's just not worth it.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:29PM (#13161064)
It will probably not surprise you that this is also the reason I no longer contribute to Wikipedia. When you're an expert in a subject, writing an encyclopedia article about it is very tedious. It's easy for me to write an explanation of how the LRNG works, or what its faults are, or what the urban mythology is about it. It's much more painful for me to do so while backing every point I make up with some secondary source --- none of which can be related to me in any way, lest I be accused of injecting my own bias into the encyclopedia.

But while I'm not going to say that the way Wikipedia deals with expertise is perfect (it is deeply imperfect), there's a sense in which this is the way it's supposed to be.

If I have important things to say about the LRNG, why would I write them in Wikipedia? Should I not write my own articles, or a chapter of a book, or an academic paper, and let people who want to write encyclopedia articles cite them? In my own work, I can obey whatever guidelines I want to, and write in whatever fashion is most gratifying and effective for me.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by jessriedel on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:59PM (#13160749)
(EDITED)

> An encyclopedia is a tertiary source: a roadmap and synopsis of existing sources.Non-notable sources are by definition those for which existing reliable sources are absent. All such articles are, in a very simple sense, "original research". One of the most basic founding principles of Wikipedia, as old as NPOV, is "no original research".... we will do so only when available sources make the job possible to do in the first place.

Why not just incorporate that into verifiability then? As I understand you, you're arguing that (1) non-notability generally implies un-verifiable, (2) Wikipedia info should be verifiable, and so (3) Wikipedia info should be notable.

Isn't it easier to demonstrate objectively that an article contains unverifiable info than it's non-notable?

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:06PM (#13160814)
I don't understand the question. That's what the standard in fact is.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by jessriedel on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:11PM (#13160862)
I expanded my comment for clarity. Let me know what you think.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:29PM (#13161074)
The notability guideline is part of the verifiability requirement.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by jessriedel on Monday December 12, 2016 @04:04PM (#13161888)
Yes I know. Your argument sounds like you're justifying the notability guideline primarily by appealing to its implication for verifiability, and I'm asking why you don't just require verifiability (and possibly making it more stringent).
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by StavrosK on Monday December 12, 2016 @05:43PM (#13162722)
> I don't understand how this is a "proxy metric".

I didn't say it was, I asked if it was.

> Non-notable sources are by definition those for which existing reliable sources are absent.

This would also make them non-verifiable, no?

> Wikipedia is committed to minimizing error.

That's fair.