News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by redler on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:09PM (#13160231)
Perhaps Wikipedia should approach this from another angle: loosen their baseline criteria, and then treat "notability" like Twitter's "verified" tag. Let the debate be whether or not an article should have the notability checkmark, not whether or not it should exist at all (within reason).
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:15PM (#13160300)
Because of the way Google prefers Wikipedia articles over other sources in its SERPs, this would ultimately have the effect of turning Wikipedia into a UGC version of AOL: it would be overrun with crud (because the Internet incentivizes Wikipedia articles), and the project would have to expend significant effort at retraining the Internet to look for "verified" stickers on the things that actually were encyclopedia articles. For what benefit?

Wikipedia's response to this problem is the right one: there's a whole big wide Internet out there, and if Wikipedia isn't the appropriate place for your article, surely there are many other places that are. UGC sites are falling over themselves to get people to write on them. Why force them on the one Internet project that doesn't want them?

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by redler on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:30PM (#13160467)
Good point on SERPs, and certainly nobody should force Wikipedia to act against what they believe is their strategic best interest. But isn't "the way Google prefers Wikipedia articles over other sources in its SERPs" an epiphenomenon? In an alternate universe where Wikipedia was more inclusive and used some kind of "notability" flag, Google could just as easily prefer those "notable" articles the way it prefers Wikipedia articles more generally in this universe.

Edit: clarity.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:39PM (#13160557)
I think it is indeed the case that if Wikipedia was subjected to less entropy, so that its editors could work on building up the encyclopedia in a sort of secluded peace, the project would be far less itchy about notability.

But remember that minimizing error is only half the argument for notability. The other half is, again, definitional: an article about a non-notable topic is almost by definition original research, and "no original research" is one of Wikipedia's oldest rules. The project's charter is to be a tertiary source.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Natsu on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:47PM (#13160633)
> an article about a non-notable topic is almost by definition original research, and "no original research" is one of Wikipedia's oldest rules

While I understand it as a means to keep random cranks out of the science pages, all it has ever incentivized is to have people 'launder' their research via some 'reliable source'.

But which sources are 'reliable' is quite often purely a matter of editorial bias and there are other wiki projects with a very different take on the matter, for example:

https://infogalactic.com/info/Infogalactic:Reliability

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:00PM (#13160765)
Could you be more specific about this "laundering" of research through reliable sources?

I definitely saw savvy Wikipedia spammers lawyering their way into the encyclopedia, sometimes successfully, for instance by citing marginal trade press cites as evidence of notability ("my client is notable because one time a trade press writer got a quote from them on the importance of FCIP products for disaster recovery programs").

What I don't see is a lot of bogus research hiding in the secondary sources of major articles.

Whatever you might think about WP's policies on what does or doesn't constitute a "reliable" source, I think it's difficult to argue that any community outside of Wikipedia has spent more time thinking about this problem.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Natsu on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:35PM (#13161127)
It's simple, you put it on your web page with some puffed-up credentials and then have a friend link to it. This works better for things that aren't commonly challenged as it often doesn't stand up to more than casual scrutiny as you do have to pass yourself off as somehow 'reliable'.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:47PM (#13161246)
My experience editing Wikipedia suggests to me that this is a dubious tactic. Anything I cited on my own web pages, for topics I feel pretty comfortable asserting expertise on (like, for instance, the presence of a lisp interpreter embedded in the Seatbelt ACL system in OSX) was immediately sniped by other editors.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Natsu on Monday December 12, 2016 @02:48PM (#13161265)
You made the mistake of citing yourself instead of getting a friend to do it :)
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by jessedhillon on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:25PM (#13160411)
Google can easily retrain itself to weight verified Wikipedia topics higher than unverified. There is a lot of benefit to having these articles maintained by a non-profit; Wikia's load time on a phone browser is stupid long, mainly because of ads and tracking scripts. It is several seconds before they are loaded, then you start getting bombarded with full-screen ads. There are dozens of Wikia apps in the Play store, so effectively that means that, unless this is a topic that I have a deep and pre-existing commitment to, I can't have the accelerated app experience. Wikia is just not a replacement for Wikipedia.

Yes, UGC sites are clamoring for content: so they can monetize the shit out of it with no respect for the content, community, creator, or reader. Your comment makes it seem like there's no merit to keeping the content on WP, but if you actually use some of these other sites I don't know how you can even compare the two.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by crdoconnor on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:49PM (#13161761)
Totally coincidentally Jimmy Wales makes money from wikia, which is a convenient home for all of those articles deleted from Wikipedia.

Plastered in advertising of course.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by rangibaby on Monday December 12, 2016 @10:06PM (#13164120)
Wikia is the reason Wikipedia's constant begging for money really annoys me.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by pwdisswordfish on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:37PM (#13160539)
Something sort of like it already exists; it's called a 'Featured Article' badge. But since there is an expectation that every article should eventually reach 'featured' status (or at least it should be possible in principle), it doesn't have the result you'd expect.

And why wouldn't people have this expectation? Why keep an article at all if it's just going to lie there and gather dust, unmaintained and exposed to vandalism?

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Sir_Substance on Monday December 12, 2016 @07:15PM (#13163373)
>unmaintained and exposed to vandalism?

Well written articles that contain no speculation shouldn't rot.

>Bill cosby is a well respected television figure

Would be badly written content that, left unmaintained, would now be inaccurate.

>Bill cosby is a television figure who was held in high regard during the 70's-90's

Is better written, because it hinges on verifiable information that will not change. It would become incomplete if no one added to it, but I would argue that it is better to have incomplete information than no information.

Vandalism issues are a problem with the wikipedia software, not a problem with the concept of having lesser-trafficked pages. If this is an issue for low-traffic pages, then there should be an anti-vandalism queue where edits to articles that receive less than a certain amount of traffic should be put in a queue to be reviewed for vandalism (and just vandalism, not content accuracy etc). It might take a while for edits to bubble through, but that's basically ok if the page receives that little traffic. Eventual information is better than no information.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by pwdisswordfish on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @06:00AM (#13165982)
> Well written articles that contain no speculation shouldn't rot.

And who is going to ensure that they are well-written and contain no speculation?

> Vandalism issues are a problem with the wikipedia software, not a problem with the concept of having lesser-trafficked pages.

If you mean to say that any software explicitly written for the purpose of letting random people publish content instantaneously with no supervision is bad software, I might agree. Otherwise, no. Vandalism is a social problem resulting from lack of article oversight. And I'm not just talking about inserting 'PENIS' into pages, because that is basically solved already with edit filters. I am talking about hoaxes, I am talking about presenting speculation as fact, I am talking about fabricated citations, I am also talking about well-meaning people who inadvertently turn carefully written technical articles into Potato Jesus. A while ago, I've looked at https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Blue_Screen_of_De... which contains this lovely sentence:

> Windows 98 and early builds of Windows Vista displayed the red screen from a boot loader error raised by ACPI.[19][20][21]

Cited to three sources. Looks great, doesn't it? But if you know anything about boot loaders, about ACPI or just about Windows, you understand this sentence is complete nonsense. You don't even need to look at the citations which obviously don't say any such thing. This is no doubt a result of shoddy copyediting by someone who didn't understand the subject. What is your answer to that?

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by Sir_Substance on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @04:35PM (#13171294)
>What is your answer to that?

That you should follow the links and see if the citation matches as part of routine anti-vandalism checks.

>Cited to three sources. Looks great, doesn't it? But if you know anything about boot loaders, about ACPI or just about Windows, you understand this sentence is complete nonsense.

All that says to me is that articles about computers should be reviewed by people who know about computers, which makes total common sense.

An encyclopedia is defined as much by it's breadth as by it's depth. Cutting notable but lesser-trafficked chunks out of it to save on effort is a lazy-arse solution that lowers the usefulness of the wiki.

I'm sure you could come up with a thousand reasons why it's too hard, but that's not how you make a good wiki. Hell, it's not how you make anything good.

Ultimately, as the consumer of your product, I don't care about your troubles. Sympathetic customer fallacy applies. If wikipedia doesn't have the information I'm looking for, I won't use it. It really doesn't matter how lovely and maintainable the articles I'm not looking for are. If you wanna be proud of the work you do, you're gonna have to dig deep, maybe make some compromises, and figure it out.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:55PM (#13160703)
Here's the list of FAs, to get some sense of what the bar is here. The overwhelming majority of WP articles --- including the important ones people care about --- aren't FA's; an FA is essentially a very high quality professional grade encyclopedia article.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Featured_articles