News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by tptacek on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:06PM (#13160200)
Can you reword this? I don't understand the suggestion you're making.

I think you might be making a category error. Notability on Wikipedia isn't a reward earned by acquisition of fame; it's a level of status at which sourcing about a subject is likely to be reliable. The problem Wikipedia has isn't that no-names might get articles. It's that articles will be written about subjects for whom reliable sourcing is impossible, because no reliable source has ever deigned to write about them.

This gets us to a fundamental principle of what an encyclopedia actually is --- and to a project rule that is as old as "NPOV". An encyclopedia --- at least Wikipedia's conception --- is a tertiary source. It's a roadmap that summarizes and points to other, more in-depth sources.

By definition, if you don't have reliable sources to back the subject of an article up, it can't be hosted in an encyclopedia. The project's answer to this challenge would be, first create the reliable secondary sources you'd need to support an encyclopedia article, and then create the article itself.

Re:In Defense of Inclusionism by wolf550e on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:02PM (#13161395)
Thank you for this explanation. You're right. For people who are only mentioned in credits for TV shows and not in newspaper articles, Wikipedia is not the place to list in which other TV shows someone was credited.