News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by ghaff on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:09AM (#13159061)
>Providing dense parking garages gets a lot easier if it doesn't need to be omfortable for people to get to the cars and you don't need to be able to open the doors when parked etc.

You mean like they do in Manhattan today?

>But self-driving cars can be used to augment the transit system too.

Here's the thing. All these scenarios are possible with the addition of a $10-ish/hr driver today. Yet they don't exist. Maybe no one's made the right pitch to VCs or maybe, just maybe, there really isn't demand for this sort of thing (in the US). Variants of smaller ad hoc minibus services do exist in other countries.

Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by vidarh on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:59AM (#13159568)
> You mean like they do in Manhattan today?

I don't know, do they have parking garages with floors where an adult can't stand upright and can't actually get out of the cars? I know you can automate it and have robotic systems to lift cars in place etc., but that adds complexity and cost that will largely disappear if the cars can park in spaces humans can get out of all by themselves.

Maybe the robotic solutions will be the end game, but painting narrower bays for self-parking cars will be the much cheaper short term solution, and e.g. modifications to add messanine floors etc. the medium term solution.

> Here's the thing. All these scenarios are possible with the addition of a $10-ish/hr driver today. Yet they don't exist.

A $10-ish/hr driver is enough to make a big difference in cost. Let's assume some downtime for maintenance. An average 20 hour utilization over 360/days year for a car would add $72k/year in costs.

Now add in that models like Uber's are new and most places aren't anywhere close to optimizing pickup times, and most cab companies are technologically just leaving the stone age, and why should we be surprised that nobody has done exactly this yet?

There are additional differences. E.g. Tesla has indicated they want people to be able to opt-in to having your own vehicle used. The availability of cars can go through the roof without a massive increase in cost once you don't depend on a supply of drivers.

> Variants of smaller ad hoc minibus services do exist in other countries.

Actually variants of ad hoc minibus services do exist in the US too. Shuttle services from airports, for example. But they're nowhere near what I suggested.

To do this for bus lines you run into the same problem as above: Drivers is a big limiting factor. The bus companies near me constantly struggle to get enough drivers (and yes, they raise salaries, but then they'd be unable to survive under the constraints put on them - take away those salaries, and they'd have a lot more flexibility in what they'd be able to do)

Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by ghaff on Monday December 12, 2016 @01:31PM (#13160472)
>I don't know, do they have parking garages with floors where an adult can't stand upright and can't actually get out of the cars?

My understanding is that there are more sophisticated robotic garages elsewhere (probably in Japan). But attended parking lots with cars up on lifts is very common in Manhattan.

Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by vidarh on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:06PM (#13161437)
Interesting. I've never seen one in London. I think that probably speaks partly to how long the adoption cycles for these types of things are, and partly how high the property prices needs to get before they pay for themselves.
Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by ghaff on Monday December 12, 2016 @03:34PM (#13161663)
You tend to see them off to the edges of Manhattan. For the most part, land's so expensive downtown and in the central avenues that it's mostly just on-street parking and garages. But as you go out toward the rivers, there are small parking lot parcels. However, the land is still expensive enough that the space in those lots gets utilized as much as possible.

This is an extreme example but you get the idea: http://www.smalltowndjs.com/images/nyc-parking-garages-2598-...

Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by usrusr on Monday December 12, 2016 @12:50PM (#13160053)
> All these scenarios are possible with the addition of a $10-ish/hr driver today.

Which easily multiplies cost by whole numbers if you allow multiple years for the hardware to break even.

The fixed hourly cost for the driver is also why cabs are orbiting for hails (unless regulated not to) instead of waiting cold, further increasing cost per use.

With passive minutes basically free, the economic threshold between passive waiting and active orbiting would be considerably shifted, resulting in additional efficiency gains.

Re:Google’s self-driving car team prepares to spin out from ... by TillE on Monday December 12, 2016 @11:40AM (#13159379)
> All these scenarios are possible

No. You don't want to burden human drivers with, for example, the mental stress of a constantly-shifting route that would be driven by a computer-optimized shared taxi system. You also increase efficiency by 33% when you free up the driver's seat.