Re:Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest
by Broken_Hippo on Sunday December 11, 2016 @09:24AM
(#13151173)
It isn't that it isn't integral - in fact, I see it as integral enough that I truly think Chicago keeps the midwest alive, at least portions of it. It is just different. A lot of the problems that other midwestern cities have - decline of factories, for example - chicago is able to make up for to an extent. And to me, that is the main thing: The chicago experience doesn't match the average Midwestern city experience - and discussing chicago directly takes a bit of time. Hence the exclusion in the article.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Let’s relocate a bunch of government agencies to the Midwest
by vinay427 on Sunday December 11, 2016 @10:29AM
(#13151430)
This seems like you're justifying the "if it doesn't fit the narrative, it doesn't count" case that I mentioned. Chicago is still a Midwestern city whether it's doing well or it's doing poorly, just as Detroit is a Midwestern city when it was booming decades ago and when it's not currently. "Midwest" is a geographic and perhaps cultural term, not a term that refers to failing cities.