It does a pretty good job of capturing the idea that, e.g., you can't patent "packet filtering" but you may[1] be able to patent a specific process for packet filtering that, say, minimizes how many bytes of each packet you have to process.
[1] Whether you should be able to patent a specific process for packet filtering is a different question. I'm not saying Alice is a good articulation of what the law should be. But I think it's a decent way of thinking about patents and coming up with the "right answer" as section 101 intends to define what the right answer is.
Then we get into questions about whether it's an "improper" type of abstractness, which is totally unworkable and hasn't been fleshed out by the courts.
The Supreme Court should have just said what they appear to have meant--that business methods are ineligible subject matter.
Surely you don't count Alice among the "level-headed" opinions? Supreme Court opinions relating to patent law almost invariably feel (to me) like they're written by a bunch of people who don't know much about patents and don't care to learn.