Re:When antibiotics failed a severely ill patient, a virus s...
by maxerickson on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:22PM
(#13133920)
More importantly - is mutation rate what we want to consider?
I think it is quite important when considering this particular interaction. Horizontal gene transfer will help a population of bacteria share a successful strategy, rampant mutation will help the virus try more strategies.
The article mentions that the particular infection reached a balance with the phage overnight, so it is likely to be a quite an issue. But the population of bacteria resistant to the phage had become susceptible to an antibiotic (for reasons related to the resistance). So it can still be a valuable tool, even if resistance happens quickly.
More importantly - is mutation rate what we want to consider? Bacteria exchange DNA with each other through horizontal gene transfer and Wikipedia quotes that as the main means of transmitting antibacterial resistance, for example [2], even across species (to the extent that bacterial species are even well-defined). I'm not sure how to make the comparison with that to viral mutation rates. This [3] source gives the following interesting, but imprecise, quote:
> This antagonistic coevolution results from the constant emergence of countermeasures by which bacteria resist phages, while phages, mutating at a more rapid rate than their prey, find means to overcome this resistance.
The paper it cites [4], definitely shows phage evolution alongside bacteria evolving counter-measures. So I think that's enough to answer the original question posed, though the question of "which is evolving faster" is harder to answer and probably isn't very well-posed.
That all said, I know nothing about this field and would be happy for some better insight.
[1] http://www.nature.com/nrmicro/journal/v11/n5/box/nrmicro3003... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horizontal_gene_transfer [3] http://cid.oxfordjournals.org/content/48/8/1096.full [4] http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/royprsb/269/1...