News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by ahoyhere on Sunday May 02, 2010 @06:25PM (#1313351)
People made the same arguments when Jobs killed the floppy. And serial ports.

And OS 9.

And built-in modems.

Surprisingly, nobody misses them.

Yawn. More histrionic nerd-posturing. It will be forgotten soon enough.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by sendos on Sunday May 02, 2010 @07:17PM (#1313461)
Weren't there adapters/peripherals so people who had floppy disks and monitors with serial ports could still use them? (e.g. this one for floppy disks: http://www.jr.com/lacie/pe/LAC_706018)

That is, if you had a floppy disk that you had to read, there was a workaround, even if Macs stopped supporting them natively.

There is no adapter/peripheral/workaround to view some website with Flash that you want to view. (Unless you consider it a workaround to carry, alongside your iPad, a laptop so that you can view websites that haven't yet transitioned to HTML5)

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by derefr on Sunday May 02, 2010 @08:08PM (#1313569)
Just to be snide: there are plenty of VNC clients for the iPhone OS, which let you view the screen of a full-powered computer, and click and type into it. This would be the same workaround you'd use if you had to run, say, an industrial control system on your iPad. It's also a pretty good idea, UI-wise: since it overlays the mouse metaphor onto your touchpad, the resulting Flash doesn't require adaptation to be used.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by rit on Monday May 03, 2010 @11:20AM (#1314917)
By way of disclaimer... I recently switched off of iPhone in favor of Android - primarily because AT&T's network sucked and not really as any statement against Apple (I refused to continue paying monthly for a phone which had no reception through much of my workday).

Overall, as a developer I'm highly in favor of open platforms, language choice, etc. However, I can't help but thinking that a tightly controlled application space the way that Apple has maintained so far is what has helped make the iPhone and iPad successful. One thing I notice on android is the lack of consistency in UIs. Sometimes the back button takes me back a screen in an App - sometimes it dumps me back to the Home screen. Sometimes it dumps me back to the last App I was using.

The iPhone apps tend to look relatively uniform UI wise and behave as expected. Encouraging the idea of cross platform apps means you start to get less and less "platform integration". It means we end up with 4 or 5 smartphone platforms none of which have any advantage because they're all running inconsistent crap.

I want my hardware + software platforms to be able to be unique and tailored towards themselves. I have seen very few truly cross platform apps which actually work well. iTunes itself is a great example - it acts weirdly and looks woefully out of place on Windows. It's the ugly duckling, and it behaves like someone chopped one of it's legs off.

The benefits of tailoring software to a particular platform should be obvious, and I much prefer them.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by ZeroGravitas on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:12AM (#1314497)
He got rid of the floppy in the first gen NeXT machines too early. You were supposed to just transfer everything via the network. He was wrong and everyone missed them and he brought them back for the second gen.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by euroclydon on Sunday May 02, 2010 @06:49PM (#1313400)
That's funny. When you said: "built-in modems", I turned my Macbook up to the side, and sure enough... no modem.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by blogimus on Sunday May 02, 2010 @08:27PM (#1313594)
And funny enough, I don't miss not having a modem on my macbook, not in the least. I also have a thinkpad which I never use the modem either, and my now long in the tooth Palm TX which doesn't have one (yeah, its a PDA, so we normally don't expect it to have one, but then why do we expect a notepbook to have a modem, because they have? That is the same argument as "It was good enough for my daddy so it is good enough for me."

And as another poster wrote, we can always vote with our dollars.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by dalore on Monday May 03, 2010 @09:02AM (#1314667)
I would say usb killed floppies and serial ports.

Built-in modems aren't dead, they are still on a surprisingly number of laptops.

He killed OS 9 so he could sell OS X. That's like saying Microsoft killed Win95. That's planned obsolescence.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by CamperBob on Sunday May 02, 2010 @06:51PM (#1313403)
Killing Turing equivalence is a bigger deal than killing RS-232 ports and floppy drives.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by pohl on Sunday May 02, 2010 @07:15PM (#1313454)
Are there really 9 readers of HN (you and 8 positive mods) who think that neither C, nor Objective C, nor C++, nor JavaScript are as Turing equivalent as any programming language can be said to be whilst constrained in a finite amount of memory?

How else could one be said to have "killed" Turing equivalence unless it didn't remain after other source languages were excluded?

Melodrama trumps computer science today?

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by prodigal_erik on Sunday May 02, 2010 @08:36PM (#1313606)
Turing equivalence guarantees there's a way to write a program in some other language that produces exactly the same results as a program in ObjC. This deep compatibility made it feasible for the industry to adopt better and better languages. But now Apple wants to put a stop to it and enshrine a few decrepit languages with flaws most of us escaped a decade ago.

(As I understand it, JavaScript doesn't belong on the list. It's permitted, but some of the Cocoa Touch API isn't accessible, so it's not really a substitute for the others.)

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by GHFigs on Sunday May 02, 2010 @09:48PM (#1313714)
But now Apple wants to put a stop to it and enshrine a few decrepit languages with flaws most of us escaped a decade ago.

Your opinion of the languages does not trump the reality that the overwhelming majority of iPhone OS applications were written in them, as was the OS itself, even when it was not a requirement. Trying to make it sound like recent changes to the App Store agreement are the only reason people use Objective-C is a big stretch.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by prodigal_erik on Monday May 03, 2010 @04:13AM (#1314319)
I know that ObjC has always been heavily used in NEXTSTEP and OS X apps (if not a lot else) even before this. My concern is that mainstream vendors will conclude that we tolerate this sort of abuse, and the problem will spread. I care that the industry permits good languages to exist, not whether the majority are interested in using them.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by defen on Monday May 03, 2010 @12:28AM (#1313995)
To be fair, that program in some other language only produces the "same results" - there's no guarantee it won't be significantly slower or use significantly more memory. Which is exactly Steve's point.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by boucher on Monday May 03, 2010 @02:39AM (#1314188)
Nor is there any guarantee it won't be significantly faster or use significantly less memory, which is the OP's point.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by jrockway on Sunday May 02, 2010 @09:34PM (#1313700)
If there's no difference between languages, why not just require everyone to use a Turing machine? It's just as easy, right, because they're all turing-equivalent.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by jules on Sunday May 02, 2010 @08:08PM (#1313568)
Well, yeah, but you're not allowed to exploit this turing equivalence.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by spot on Sunday May 02, 2010 @10:28PM (#1313777)
it was killed for users, not for developers.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by CamperBob on Sunday May 02, 2010 @09:30PM (#1313692)
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by pohl on Sunday May 02, 2010 @10:23PM (#1313767)
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by CamperBob on Sunday May 02, 2010 @10:47PM (#1313800)
What's more melodramatic than a company like Apple being afraid of an app like Scratch?
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by pohl on Monday May 03, 2010 @08:41AM (#1314624)
While your post has the superficial form that a retort might have, that word doesn't mean what you think it means...

Melodrama: (noun) a sensational dramatic piece with exaggerated characters and exciting events intended to appeal to the emotions. Language, behavior, or events that resemble drama of this kind.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by CamperBob on Monday May 03, 2010 @04:38PM (#1315999)
If you don't see Jobs's writings on the subject as emotionally overwrought appeals ("We have to keep our platform pure to protect you, our loyal user!"), we'll have to agree to disagree.

This is exactly like a "Won't somebody think of the children?" appeal. What else do you call it when the company rejects both a programming tool and a dictionary for "bad language?"

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by pohl on Monday May 03, 2010 @05:52PM (#1316215)
"We have to keep our platform pure to protect you, our loyal user!"

If you want to make a case that they are making emotionally overwrought appeals, you should have the decency to provide a direct quote to make your case. Abusing quotations marks by putting them around your own subjective interpretation just tells me that you've got nothing to offer.

Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by CamperBob on Monday May 03, 2010 @07:04PM (#1316384)
If I were being paid to make a formal argument, perhaps you'd be correct. As it is, I think you know very well what's meant, and that it is an accurate paraphrasing of Jobs's words in light of his actions.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by pohl on Monday May 03, 2010 @11:04PM (#1316871)
I think it's a common way haters lampoon it, but I think it shows poor comprehension of the message.
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by akshaybhat on Monday May 03, 2010 @01:16AM (#1314061)
yeah why dont you try coding in Assembly for that matter or even better submit the circuit designs,
Re:Steve Jobs, circa 2020: "Thoughts on country roads" by sambeau on Monday May 03, 2010 @06:08AM (#1314438)
You are allowed to program in C++ and C, too. There is also a good chance that Ruby will join that list as soon as the LLVM version (that Apple is working on) is finished.

(see http://www.macruby.org/)