Re:Penny-Arcade TV on chronic anxiety and antidepressants
by pw0ncakes on Sunday May 02, 2010 @10:38AM
(#1312518)
Panic attacks can be reliably produced in normal people with certain drugs, leading to the implication of biological causes.
Anxious people tend to be more prone to panic attacks. A panic attack usually begins with a benign biological malfunction (misfiring of adrenal gland, slight breathing irregularity set off by allergies) that would otherwise be mild and possibly ignored, but if it launches a feedback loop of negative and anxious thoughts, it can become panic.
So the cause is, in part, biological. That doesn't mean that cognitive-behavior therapy in addition to drugs isn't usually a good idea.
Re:Penny-Arcade TV on chronic anxiety and antidepressants
by Tichy on Sunday May 02, 2010 @12:25PM
(#1312672)
I don't agree that drug-induced panic attacks implicate biological causes. In the end, everything has a biological cause - a brain cell is just a biological thing, nerves are just a biological thing. What happens in their interaction is what matters.
Not saying that there can not be biological causes (malfunctioning nerves/brain/whatever), but it doesn't exclude the possibility of "logical" causes.
That doesn't imply drugs are the wrong treatment. Maybe circumstances like the ones you experience are like accidents that break things. If some treatment can help the healing, why not. It just seems dangerous to assume that one can not live without the drugs forever after.