I do think your first sentence has some truth, but I wouldn't use Thiel as a reference as it just seems to be an appeal to emotion.
Is there any evidence backing up Thiel's assertion? It sounds like romanticizing the past and idealizing eccentricity. It's also begging the question that eccentric/idiosyncratic people make the best scientists.
For another example, here is Peter Higgs (the guy who developed the theory that predicted the boson) discussing modern science: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/dec/06/peter-higgs-.... As far as quantitative data about trends in scientific funding - we have lots of data showing that the funding climate is the worse it's ever been, but I wouldn't even know how to quantitatively prove that being 'strategic' is more important now than it was in the past.
As a side ntoe, John Oliver does a great segment on how mainstream media miscommunicates scientific results
Peter Thiel said that: "the political people who are nimble in the art of writing government grants have gradually displaced the eccentric and idiosyncratic people who typically make the best scientists. The eccentric university professor is a species that is going extinct fast" - and that's exactly right. Cuddy is a terrible scientist, but she's a fantastic communicator, an engaging speaker, and a great 'seller'.
How do we fix this? Brian Nosek is doing some absolutely fantastic work on this, and I hope it picks up more traction, but I'd like to see the ecosystem around scientific communication seriously revamped. There are a few publications (the Economist and the Atlantic come to mind) that have excellent scientific writers, but things like TED or Malcom Gladwell's books are a blight upon science.