Those statements are so incredibly antithetical to the ethos of science. It amazes me they could say something like that and keep face among their peers. My hope is that history does not look kindly on such words.
Re:Power Poser: When big ideas go bad
by Bartweiss on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @12:12PM
(#13168422)
Those comments are shockingly close to just announcing "caring whether my studies are right gets in the way of my career".
I realize that good social scientists may get stuck falling behind bad ones in reputation, and I think that's a structural problem. But responding to that with a demand to stop checking for bad results is shocking, and it's not something that should be acceptable for a practicing researcher. I hope those voices don't slow down the effort to reform these fields.
Peer review serves a useful, but limited, function. In a case like this, the important issue is that failures to replicate can also be published.
Re:Power Poser: When big ideas go bad
by drspacemonkey on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @07:49PM
(#13119623)
A few weeks ago, I managed to catch blame for finding a bug in our software as if I had created the bug. So "the bad guy is the one who uncovered it" makes sense. At least, in a very depressing way.
>such criticism could have a "chilling effect on science."
>"destructo-critics" engaged in "methodological terrorism."
wonderful. Can be used as responses to [unfavorable] code reviews. Especially effective if typed in while taking a power pose.
Yikes. So when a study is seriously flawed, the bad guy is the one who uncovered it? I'm more concerned that peer reviewers aren't searching hard enough for errors.