Re:Hard Truths and Happiness
by mcguire on Sunday December 04, 2016 @10:56AM
(#13100320)
"In order to develop this further we might consider a popular critical image of Stoicism: a Stoic is someone who is powerless in the real world and so pretends that his or her happiness is something completely internal and within their own control. Got no money? Easy, just say that money is unnecessary for a good life and the problem is solved. According to a long line of modern critics of Stoicism from Hegel onwards, the Stoic is someone who lies themselves out of reality in order to feel happy in otherwise unpleasant circumstances. It is an example of what Nietzsche called a ‘slave morality’, ultimately grounded in powerlessness and an inability to face up to some hard truths about life."
1. Well, Stoicism and its nigh identical twin Epicureanism are a response to the fading of classical Greece post Alexander and in the face of the rise of Rome. The idea that they are powerless and "slave" philosophies is kinda true.
2. The rest of the article does not dispute the first sentence; we all really are powerless in the face of death, etc., etc. The issue the article has is with the word "pretends".
1. Well, Stoicism and its nigh identical twin Epicureanism are a response to the fading of classical Greece post Alexander and in the face of the rise of Rome. The idea that they are powerless and "slave" philosophies is kinda true.
2. The rest of the article does not dispute the first sentence; we all really are powerless in the face of death, etc., etc. The issue the article has is with the word "pretends".