News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by spion on Saturday December 03, 2016 @08:48PM (#13098382)
Its just not taught correctly. `this` is the hidden function argument passed by putting it left of the dot; from that, everything else follows.
Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by groovy2shoes on Sunday December 04, 2016 @06:16PM (#13102300)
Which is, of course, the same way `this` or `self` works in virtually every OO language.

I honestly thought this was common knowledge, and not that hard to grasp. How else is `this` being taught?

Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by _greim_ on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @02:33PM (#13170010)
> I honestly thought this was common knowledge

For whatever reason it isn't common knowledge in JS-land.

> How else is `this` being taught?

Sadly it very seldom is taught this way. It tends to be a realization people come to after using the language for a while [1].

[1] https://twitter.com/greim/status/778793044174704640

Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by drewgross on Monday December 05, 2016 @02:58AM (#13104022)
The difference is the JS has late binding.

  myObj.myMethod();
Has different semantics than

  var x = myObj.myMethod; 
  x();
Which causes code like:

  myList.map(myObj.myMethod);
to behave somewhat unintuitively.
Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by groovy2shoes on Thursday December 08, 2016 @10:30PM (#13136454)
Your examples don't need late binding to have different semantics — dynamic dispatch will suffice. That's not different from any other OO language (except perhaps in C++ for non-virtual methods). That's how we get polymorphism out of subtypes, after all: methods are resolved based on the dynamic value of the receiver at runtime, yielding single dynamic dispatch. Regardless of language, the `this` or `self` reference within a method always semantically behaves as if it were an additional parameter (except in typed languages where the variance under the subtyping relation is reversed, iirc), and is often implemented as such, albeit usually implicitly.

Of course, late binding implies dynamic dispatch, but the reverse isn't true. On the other hand, almost every untyped OO language uses late binding (I can't even think of one that doesn't, off the top of my head...), as do some typed languages (those that target the .NET CLR, for example), so even with your stronger assertion JS far from unique in that regard.

That behavior is standard fare for OO. If anyone finds it tricky, I find it more likely that the struggling programmer has yet to internalize OO than that JS is doing something strange (in this particular case, I mean... JS does plenty of strange shit otherwise ;) ).

Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by spion on Saturday December 10, 2016 @08:00PM (#13148965)
The difference is that JS has no binding, yet it still allows for first class methods. Thus the OO "illusion" (object owns the methods) is broken: there are no methods, just functions that take an argument named `this`, in a slightly weird way, only when attached to records.
Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by groovy2shoes on Sunday December 11, 2016 @10:37PM (#13155312)
> The difference is that JS has no binding ... just functions that take an argument named `this`

Associating a name with a value is precisely what binding is.

Frankly, though, I don't understand this comment at all. Care to clarify for me?

Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by prodigal_erik on Sunday December 11, 2016 @10:44PM (#13155358)
In Python

  b = foo.bar
  b()
correctly invokes the bar method of the foo object. In JavaScript, you have to write

  let b = foo.bar.bind(foo)
because foo.bar gives you a function (not a method) that doesn't remember which object it came from.
Re:ECMAScript bind operator proposal by groovy2shoes on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @08:11PM (#13172949)
I'm aware of what you have to write in JS, and I'd argue that that's the behavior that's to be expected. I'm actually more surprised by Python's behavior here. Lua works the same way JS does, as does Common Lisp.