Re:This AI Boom Will Also Bust
by throw_away_777 on Saturday December 03, 2016 @01:09PM
(#13096706)
It is actually much easier to apply a random forest (or really gradient boosted decision tree, which almost strictly dominates random forests) than a linear regression. Decision tree methods require far less data preprocessing than linear regression, because the model is able to infer feature relationships. Obviously if your features are linearly related to your target than linear regression is much more viable.
Re:This AI Boom Will Also Bust
by jbrambleDC on Saturday December 03, 2016 @03:32PM
(#13097373)
This is absolutely true, the one caveat is that you can explain the significance of features and the relationship to the response variables in simpler terms.
Re:This AI Boom Will Also Bust
by joe_the_user on Saturday December 03, 2016 @01:26PM
(#13096780)
Technically, it is an incorrect analogy not a false dichotomy. A false dichotomy means an incorrect assertion that you have to choose X or Y in a situation.
The GP compares python-vs-assembler and random forests-vs-linear-regression but the analogy breaks because python produces assembler and increases the programmer's general certainty concerning what they are doing. Random forests don't make their user more certain of the results as an application. Basically, Python is a relatively "unleaky" abstraction whereas complex AI algorithms a very "leaky" abstractions.
Broadly, whether you should move from OLS to random forest regression = SNR increase / increase in manhours and money spent.