Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by adrianN on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:22AM
(#13089250)
I like to think of OSM as striving be as complete and as accurate as possible. So I believe every correct piece of data should be added.
Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by maxerickson on Friday December 02, 2016 @10:57AM
(#13089619)
Sure, but a hasty import of large amounts of data that no one is around to maintain it is at odds with accuracy.
Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by toomuchtodo on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:15AM
(#13089789)
Which is why we should be encouraging government agencies to use OSM as the canonical reference.
Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by maxerickson on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:52AM
(#13090183)
It's probably going to take more than encouragement.
Namely, changes to open records laws to make it okay to work on data sets that are not strictly public domain.
Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by toomuchtodo on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:56AM
(#13090211)
Is not all map data in the US not in the public domain, being works by the government?
Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by maxerickson on Friday December 02, 2016 @11:59AM
(#13090238)
The point is that a public employee subject to open records laws can't edit OSM because OSM isn't public domain.
Here's an example. The National Park Service can't treat OSM as their canonical data store:
https://www.nps.gov/npmap/blog/nps-plus-osm-equals-places-of...
People play blame-the-ODBL, but there's not really any epically strong arguments against adjusting the public records laws to be a little more flexible.
Re:New York City mapped its trees and calculated each one’s ...
by toomuchtodo on Friday December 02, 2016 @12:37PM
(#13090597)
Thank you for sharing this!
The interest in such data is going to tend to be local or be forced to take into account the nature of the data collection (and thus benefit from directly accessing the curated source data). An example of the latter would be an academic analysis; to pull data from OSM, it would need to start by determining geographic areas with good coverage, or the results would be utterly meaningless.