Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by Dobbs on Thursday December 01, 2016 @06:50PM
(#13084720)
This honestly doesn't surprise me. Adding an infinite number of IPs is one way bot writers get around rate limits. I've done it before when I worked for a company that made a facebook/myspace/etc crawler.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by magila on Thursday December 01, 2016 @07:18PM
(#13084910)
Per IP rate limiting with IPv6 is a futile gesture against any attacker more sophisticated than a kid in his parent's basement. It doesn't take much effort to get a /48 while most ISPs are handing out /64s to their customers. This leaves rate limiters in a catch 22: Are all those requests coming from a given /48 a single attacker, or a bunch of Comcast users? It's impossible to tell without maintaining a table of what the "end user" allocation size is for a particular IP range, which would be a massive, never-ending task.
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by chipperyman573 on Thursday December 01, 2016 @07:07PM
(#13084839)
Out of curiosity, why does Amazon consider it their responsibility to prevent that? I'm personally glad that they do, but bots use resources, which is good for Amazon (money in their pocket), and as far as I know Amazon doesn't have anything it wants to protect from bots (at least, anything that would be heavily limited by IP).
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by cperciva on Thursday December 01, 2016 @08:53PM
(#13085321)
In addition to the answers other people have given about not wanting AWS IP space blacklisted, people who are intending to do use services for nefarious purposes have a nasty habit of paying for them using stolen credit cards.
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by bjeanes on Thursday December 01, 2016 @07:11PM
(#13084865)
Well, one explanation might be the reputation of their IP ranges. Already, payment processors and some mail servers will give extra scrutiny to IP ranges belonging to AWS. If AWS is made attractive to that audience and damage is done to the reputation (in various systems) of those IP ranges, their offering becomes less compelling to all customer demographics.
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by openasocket on Thursday December 01, 2016 @07:16PM
(#13084900)
From a rational self-interest standpoint, bots tend to get their IP addresses blocked by whoever they're targeting. Which means the Amazon IP address space gets on threat lists and block lists. The bot owners can just generate new instances with new IP addresses, and then some legitimate customer spins up an instance and gets their address, and wind up on blocked. The bots keep going until various services decide to just block all of Amazon's space, the same way they would for Tor exit nodes or other things associated with shady activity.
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by toomuchtodo on Thursday December 01, 2016 @07:35PM
(#13084982)
As a good netizen, you want to ensure that other providers don't blackhole your IP blocks (which they will if you allow abuse to be emitted from said IP blocks).
Re:IPv6 Support for EC2 Instances in Virtual Private Clouds
by otterley on Friday December 02, 2016 @03:05AM
(#13086964)
Infinite IP addresses aren't the same as infinite routable IP addresses. EC2 VPCs use private subnets, and instances created in VPCs don't have routable IP addresses unless you add them. It would be reasonable for AWS to allow infinite VPC subnet addresses to be attached to an instance, but only one or two public addresses.