Re:Apple killed lala.com
by jessriedel on Friday April 30, 2010 @10:05AM
(#1308173)
I'm honestly curious as to how they are allowed to do this. You contracted with lala.com for a service, and companies don't get to ignore the contracts they've made with their customers just because they are bought by other companies. Couldn't you demand your money back? Or, in principle, sue them?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
http://www.lala.com/#termsofservice (last updated in 2008, supposedly) states: "la la reserves the right to modify or discontinue any of the Services and material displayed on or offered through the Site, with or without notice to you, and is not obligated to support or update the Site or Services."
That was the contract lala made with their customer.
This exact same scenario - users losing access to music they've paid for due to a service being killed - has happened multiple times[1] due to DRM. I think it's clear that whether the reliance is on a DRM key-server, streaming, or whatever, consumers shouldn't "buy" music that stops being available when servers disappear.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_rights_management#Obsol...
Re:Apple killed lala.com
by jessriedel on Friday April 30, 2010 @01:41PM
(#1308830)
That is incredible. Why would anyone pay money for that?
I am still a bit skeptical that this would hold up in court. There are laws about what you can hide in the fine print, and often judges will hold the transaction to be for things that that a reasonable person would expect, not what is stated in the contract.
That is probably not enforceable. Unfortunately the only real option is a class action lawsuit which would probably result in a minimal rebate.
So in other words, the money given them creates absolutely no obligation on their part to do anything whatsoever.
Re:Apple killed lala.com
by evansolomon on Friday April 30, 2010 @11:55AM
(#1308494)
How could they feasibly do anything else? What do you think happens to your Facebook gifts if the company goes out of business? I bet their terms of service don't include shipping you physical strips of bacon to replace the virtual ones you lose.
Re:Apple killed lala.com
by jessriedel on Friday April 30, 2010 @01:39PM
(#1308822)
Going out of business is different than just saying "we won't honor the purchase you made anymore".
Re:Apple killed lala.com
by evansolomon on Friday April 30, 2010 @07:37PM
(#1309753)
It's always a choice. Going out of business is a choice, selling the company is a choice, and the acquiring company shutting down the acquired company's product is a choice. Any way you slice it, no matter what the circumstances, someone made a choice not to honor your purchase anymore, if that's the way you want to describe it.