News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by harryh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:41PM (#13068015)
As someone who reads reddit fairly frequently, this doesn't reflect my experience on the site. In reality there is no unified reddit. I've taken a gander at /r/The_Donald a couple of times (mostly out of morbid curiosity) but other than those few times I've experienced very little impact of whatever it is they are doing.

I read some sports subredits. I read some culture subredits. I read some of the bigger basic entertaining but silly subreddits like /r/AskReddit and /r/TodayILearned. And, to be honest, I really haven't noticed much impact by these nefarious elements (or whatever you want to call them).

I'm sure others have had different experiences from me, but from my point of view whatever "crazy shit" is going down is mostly confined to certain sub-sections of the site that are easily avoided.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by a_bonobo on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:48PM (#13068057)
Looks like it's a bigger problem for moderators than for users:

>“There have been unquestionably instances [where] moderators of other subreddits were targeted by users in The_Donald,” Reddit told Gizmodo, and the leaked chatlogs reveal the extent.

>Some moderators had been flooded with constant harassing messages. “One threatened to kill my fucking dog,” a moderator pleaded in the leaked Slack chat. A The_Donald user hacked r/politics and booted half of the moderation team, another told Gizmodo in an email.

>“We have had multiple moderators doxxed and sent death threats, we had one moderator who had his truck broken into and vandalized,” an r/politics mod told Gizmodo over Reddit private message.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by wheelerwj on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:56PM (#13068102)
Yeah, this is what was REALLY shitty about /u/Spez's debacle.

Profanity, hate speech, bullying, harassment aren't protected by free speech. And you see PLENTY of it coming out of the_donald. You don't have to tolerate that shit, you have every right to shut it down. But no, lets degrade ourselves by trolling the trolls.

What a strategic waste.

non-edit: greglindahl below me makes an excellent point on my choice of vocabulary. I won't edit my post, I'll just concede that I chose poorly while trying to articulate my point.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by greglindahl on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:08PM (#13068180)
You're being sloppy with terms. In the US, obscenity isn't protected by free speech, but non-obscene profanity is. Hate speech? Threats of violence aren't free speech, but a lot of odious hate speech is. Court cases about bullying frequently fail.

Of course Reddit, being private, has the right to do whatever it wants. But it's important to realize where the lines are drawn for public discourse.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by a_bonobo on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:10PM (#13068190)
I don't think harassment via private messages counts as public discourse
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by greglindahl on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:16PM (#13068213)
I agree. I wasn't talking about private messages in my comment. One nice thing about public discourse is that it's public, i.e., it's easy for everyone to debate how odious it is. Private messages are very different, and should be filtered quite differently.

From a sunlight point of view, being able to make private messages public is quite effective, albeit a feature which should be disclosed in advance.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by anigbrowl on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:33PM (#13068520)
Given that Reddit's business model relies on volunteer moderators (which is why I'm not shedding any tears over its problems - that's what you get for building a business on free labor), I'd say it's gonna be a big problem for their shareholders as ad revenue drops and then for the remaining users as it sinks past the threshold of tolerability.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by mikeryan on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:44PM (#13068034)
I don't see this on my own view of the site. But I click /r/all every so often just to get some variety and that's where you see this in effect. It seems an r/The_Donald post has been in one of the top two spots for the last few months with others in the queue.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by rrggrr on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:08PM (#13068177)
The average front page Reddit post is thought to require about 323,500 views says... the internet.

Trump got about 13,000,000 votes in the primary election, which is relevant because its though primary voters are more active in the political participation.

The point being, I'm not sure given current headlines and the recency of the US election, that the front page stats are out of line.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by nunez on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:02PM (#13068141)
Agreed. I normally consume Reddit via RSS and only keep up with a few subs. I haven't noticed much of the frenzy that people have been talking about.

I could imagine someone seeing this if they stick to the default front page.

Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by wheelerwj on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:54PM (#13068578)
not the default front page. it's r/all that's taken a beating as well as the comments section of other subs.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by GabberBots on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:05PM (#13068161)
Would it be fair to say that the subs you visit are not typical targets for political discussions? The problem has been the chilling effects that T_D has had within its sphere of influence. The brunt of which has been felt by the mod teams in toeing the line between free speech and preventing civil unrest.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by harryh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:07PM (#13068174)
Yes, definitely. I don't really read anything at all related to politics on reddit. Perhaps the influence of /r/The_Donald is confined to those subreddits.
Re:Reddit Is Tearing Itself Apart by senectus1 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:47PM (#13068053)
pretty much the same... but as will all echo chambers, you'll hear what you're listing to.

If people are on ranty subreddits they will hear ranty posts.

I'm happy with reddit. Its a pleasant diversion that I get to tune to my liking.