Re:The Insecurity of OpenBSD (2010)
by nickpsecurity on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @08:47PM
(#13067771)
It was straight-forward on the first system to use it: STOP OS on SCOMP & XTS-400. The STOP OS broke OS into various components layered by how privileged they were into four rings with user-mode software on lowest layer. Then, the ring protection by itself prevents (a) writes by untrusted programs to trusted programs' data or code spaces; (b) reads of secrets from privileged programs by untrusted programs. Anything security-critical is mediated by security kernel that is formally specified, verified, analyzed, tested, and pentested against a clear, security policy.
Complexity came when people wanted to apply MAC to poorly architected operating systems and programs. Especially monolithic UNIX. The LOCK program, which I link to in my main reply to OP, invented type enforcement in an effort to express vast majority of security policies for both their clean-slate, high-assurance TCB plus the UNIX VM's they were making for compatibility. Got applied to a BSD in Sidewinder firewall, then applied to microkernels at Utah in form of Flask architecture, and then ported as SELinux to Linux. As you can see, a series of tough compromises from Linux's insecure design plus the fact it was basically an academic hack led to its complexity and issues.
Simpler ones included LOMAC, rule-set based methods, Windows Integrity Control (similar to STOP's), and so on. TOMOYO and AppArmor at least did a learning mode that acceptance testing could feed. Capsicum brings capability-security model to FreeBSD on top of SEBSD enhancements. It's not kludgy MAC or nothing. There's middle ground.
Complexity came when people wanted to apply MAC to poorly architected operating systems and programs. Especially monolithic UNIX. The LOCK program, which I link to in my main reply to OP, invented type enforcement in an effort to express vast majority of security policies for both their clean-slate, high-assurance TCB plus the UNIX VM's they were making for compatibility. Got applied to a BSD in Sidewinder firewall, then applied to microkernels at Utah in form of Flask architecture, and then ported as SELinux to Linux. As you can see, a series of tough compromises from Linux's insecure design plus the fact it was basically an academic hack led to its complexity and issues.
Simpler ones included LOMAC, rule-set based methods, Windows Integrity Control (similar to STOP's), and so on. TOMOYO and AppArmor at least did a learning mode that acceptance testing could feed. Capsicum brings capability-security model to FreeBSD on top of SEBSD enhancements. It's not kludgy MAC or nothing. There's middle ground.