Re:The Probability and Statistics Cookbook
by nonbel on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:57PM
(#13066585)
You may also want to check out figure 2 of this paper which further illustrates the relationship between a statistical hypothesis and the research hypothesis:
http://rhowell.ba.ttu.edu/Meehl1.pdf
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Probability and Statistics Cookbook
by justifier on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @09:52AM
(#13071170)
> Ten years later, I wrote at greater length along similar lines (Meehl, 1978); but, despite my having received more than 1,000 reprint requests for that article in the first year after its appearance, I cannot discern that it had more impact on research habits in soft psychology than did Morrison and Henkel.
is the author using a null value to inform this perception?
Re:The Probability and Statistics Cookbook
by nonbel on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @04:16PM
(#13074763)
Doesn't sound like it. It sounds like Meehl is giving an order of magnitude estimate. He is saying that it is his impression that both Morrison & Henkel's paper and his own seemed to have little effect on practice.
Clearly he doesn't think it had exactly zero effect, since it affected him!
Re:The Probability and Statistics Cookbook
by justifier on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @06:26PM
(#13075638)
assuming 1000 reprints somehow implies there should be a discernible 'impact on research habits' seems like an example of what your referenced Figure 2(o) calls 'Estimating parameters from sample'
Re:The Probability and Statistics Cookbook
by nonbel on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @07:01PM
(#13075835)
You have it reversed.
"Estimating parameters from sample" (on the right) would be his observation that there was little discernible effect. Thinking that 1000 reprints of the paper would have a larger effect on practice would more correspond to "theory" (on the left), although that is a pretty vague one.