Email works significantly better than fax: it just appears to have more problems due to volume of electronic mail.
not that i like fax, but the experience you get with the average office supply store fax machine is a poor one.
- dealing with attachments (no high quality images via fax)
- attachment filetype (speed negotiation)
- clean paper underflowing
- fax machine runs out of memory and rejects a too large fax without confirmation on the other side
- phone line administration
- takes a phone line / number
- spam (also exists via fax)
- spam false positives (if you have enough people in the office, someone will file your message into the bin by accident one day)
- if you really really care, you can actually call the recipient of your email, which will work the same way the fax does
- recipient must print the fax even if it's spam, one sentence, or something that has to be typed in again and forwarded by email
Both emails and faxes "just work" most of the time. They're really quite similar after all.
The fax use case is: a businessperson needs to walk to a machine, lay a stack of 50 sheets down, punch in an address and let the machine do the rest. Oh, so you say some scanners/copiers can email? Let's go over the problems with email.
- dealing with attachments
- attachment filetype; no enforceable standard by the recipient
- inboxes overflowing
- smtp servers rejecting messages over a certain unknown size
- mailserver administration
- chews through Internet bandwidth; no built-in throttling
- spam
- spam false positives, dropped messages
- no ability to reliably confirm delivery
- recipient has to print document, for full fax simulation
I'm actually amazed there has been no Internet standard that has emerged for this: pushing a large document in some standard format to an Internet-connected client computer (laptop or desktop, not dedicated server) for immediate viewing/printing. The cynic in me says the anti -P2P movement had a lot to do with it, since a P2P file transfer is about as close as we have to fax functionality (albeit with some problems of its own). There are obviously many ways to cobble together HTTP, FTP, SFTP, XMPP, etc. to imitate this use case, but none really come close to the plug-it-in-and-hit-start ease of fax machines.