News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by Trundle on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:34PM (#13060818)
Not familiar with "two wrongs don't make a right"?
Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by grzm on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:42PM (#13060850)
I think you're implying that those punishments are wrong. What would be justice in your eyes for the three crimes described? To mine, the proportionality seems more than a little out of whack.

- Stolen TV (let's say $1000 burglary)

- Stolen car (let's say $15,000)

- $500MM fraud

Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by Trundle on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:02AM (#13060961)
Mostly I'm implying that your argument doesn't hold weight. You don't throw someone in prison because if you don't there's a double standard with some other offence. You throw them in there because the crime they committed warranted it.

I'll play anyway for funzies though. First offence?

All 3 should be a non-bankruptable fine with a floor that also scales with historical earnings and wealth. I can't give specific numbers because I think it should be set at figures large enough to act as a suitable deterrent which I don't know and would need to research. Since in a scenario where I'm magically put in charge of the legal system I would have the means and incentive to do that research, I think that's fair on my part. Potentially some public shaming involving stocks and vegetable throwing depending on its cost effectiveness as a deterrent as well.

I imagine the fine amount would be far greater for the fraud though, which would help with the lack of proportionality.

Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by qyv on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:51AM (#13061150)
I'm curious, so what do you do if the fine is never paid?

ETA: IS a non-bankruptable fne proportional if the fraud actually bankrupted many others? What if the consequence of the fraud on said victims then led them to further crimes which led them to a ruined life of pverty and squalor? Is a non-bankruptable fine still proportionate? What if it led to suicide, or armed robbery, or even murder...

Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:06AM (#13060978)
Thank you for a much more thoughtful comment. I think you make a lot of good points. Do you think that the fines should be proportionate with respect to the status of the person convicted?

I think one issue is the perception that some very rich people can afford to pay those large fines, which acts as less of a deterrent.

Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by Trundle on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:36AM (#13061080)
Absolutely, that's what I meant by "scales with historical earnings and wealth."
Re:How Elizabeth Warren Took Down the CEO of Wells Fargo, an... by grzm on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:49AM (#13061139)
So you did. Sorry I missed that. Cheers!