Re:Choke Point of a Nation: The High Cost of an Aging River ...
by dragonwriter on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:38PM
(#13058199)
> The issue with proportional representation is that it may reduce the concentration of power amongst the parties, but it will make political parties more important than individual representatives, and promote a hyper-partisan attitude.
What you say is arguably a valid concern for one particular method of achieving proportional representation (the Party List Proportional method), but there is no clear reason it would be for other methods of promoting proportionality (such as multimember districts with candidate-centered elections using Single Transferrable Vote.)
> When turning out 'your side' is more important than convincing the median voter, the parties will focus on their bases,
That's already exactly the case with the US system, where elections are won more by turnout and less by conversions. The duopoly naturally produced by FPTP makes efforts to depress turnout of the other sides likely voters (whether by targeted propaganda or actual suppression) a strong tactic.
What you say is arguably a valid concern for one particular method of achieving proportional representation (the Party List Proportional method), but there is no clear reason it would be for other methods of promoting proportionality (such as multimember districts with candidate-centered elections using Single Transferrable Vote.)
> When turning out 'your side' is more important than convincing the median voter, the parties will focus on their bases,
That's already exactly the case with the US system, where elections are won more by turnout and less by conversions. The duopoly naturally produced by FPTP makes efforts to depress turnout of the other sides likely voters (whether by targeted propaganda or actual suppression) a strong tactic.