Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by ASpring on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:09PM
(#13057974)
Your condescending remarks ("...someone paid attention in his middle-school statistics club") detract from what is otherwise a very useful comment.
Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by minimaxir on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:42PM
(#13058234)
OP of the article here.
Microaggressions aside, these are fair counterpoints. I spent far less time editing the body of the post than optimizing the visualizations/Jupyter Notebook (especially in this particular post). I've taken more care in future posts since.
Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by tedsanders on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:30PM
(#13058608)
If you are looking for feedback, here is another suggestion for future posts: I found the use of violin plots for discrete data to be confusing. To be honest, I still am not sure how to interpret the unlabeled Y axis. I think a histogram would have been easier for me (and others) to interpret.
But suggestions aside, I found your article to be interesting. Thank you for it.
Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by joshuahhh on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:33PM
(#13060817)
I second the criticism of using violin plots here. A violin plot is a kernel density plot. It is designed to show a distribution at a scale much larger than variations in the data. Its raison d'etre is to smooth out and aggregate these small-scale variations.
But in this survey data, the values in the distribution are spaced far apart. The discretization is so large that the violin plots show meaningless and weirdly inconsistent curves between x-values which actually have data. A bar plot would be much clearer.
OP, I think you have done a fine job of styling your plots tastefully. But I recommend taking another look at the visual language you have chosen to communicate the data.
Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by minimaxir on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:44AM
(#13061520)
Agreed. The violin plot was an experiment that did not work out in retrospect.
Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by vadman on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:07PM
(#13064329)
I learned that violin plots exist, so your experiment was worth it to me :)
Re:Visualizing How Developers Rate Their Own Programming Skills
by baloneyman on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:27AM
(#13064018)
I liked it :)
- people are "dishonest" (My intuition would point to a subconscious bias more than actual dishonesty)
- It's a minority (The second chart shows that >50% of respondents with one year of experience or less rate themselves as better than average).
- That subconscious biases only work in one direction
... and once again I have no idea how confidence intervals can help. A large interval may indicate bad measurement. It may also indicate high variability in the actual data.
... someone paid attention in his middle-school statistics club... ... but failed statistics 101. A regression analysis doesn't care about causality. If "Mac users are more likely to be college-educated" it doesn't matter that "buying a Mac may not actually make you smarter". I can still make the prediction "a given Mac user is more likely to have a college degree".