News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by matt4077 on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:30PM (#13057350)
> On the contrary it can put all their business at total risk.

...mostly by regulation, right?

I mean – we can all hope that all parent read about all accidents that kill people and then independently come to the smart conclusion, including a level-headed appreciation of the risk, normalized within the background context and the market penetration of ultra-strong magnets...

or – better idea – let's put some smart people in a room and let them make a recommendation.

There's even a staunchly capitalistic argument for regulation: it's the only reason we trust food from a supermarket we've never visited before, or a new toy, or an online bank, or a really fast looking electric car from California made by this guy who mostly deals in explosions controlled by 400,000 mechanical parts all supplied by the lowest bidder.

In other words: Regulation creates the trust that's essential for any economic activity.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by tn13 on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:57PM (#13057537)
> ...mostly by regulation, right?

Mostly by bad reviews, lawsuites and bad PR. One good example of this is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide

While everyone thinks that it was an evil pharma that should have stopped by regulators it appears that the pharma company lost billions but saved by regulators instead.

>we can all hope that all parent read about all accidents that kill people and then independently come to the smart conclusion

Neither parent not bureaucrats can do that 100% correctly. Parents can do it infinitely better that the people in washington. Babies will die no matter what.

> let's put some smart people in a room and let them make a recommendation.

Like smart people deciding on housing loans, student loans, cheaper healthcare, invasion of Iraq ? It eventually snowballs into a giant problem that makes the original problem far less worse.

Smart people do not possess the intelligence or information to make decisions for others.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by matt4077 on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:08PM (#13057972)
You're really bringing Thalidomide, of all examples?

To quite the Wikipedia article you linked:

    For correctly denying the application despite the 
    pressure from Richardson-Merrell, Kelsey eventually 
    received the President's Award for Distinguished
    Federal Civilian Service at a 1962 ceremony with 
    President John F. Kennedy. In September 2010, the 
    FDA honored Kelsey with the first Kelsey award. 

    The award, given annually to an FDA staff member, 
    came 50 years after Kelsey, then a new medical 
    officer at the agency, first reviewed the application
    from the William S. Merrell Company of Cincinnati.[109]
   
    Cardiologist Helen B. Taussig learned of the damaging 
    effects of the drug thalidomide on newborns and in 1967,
    testified before Congress on this matter after a trip to
 
    Germany where she worked with infants with
    phocomelia (severe limb deformities). 

    As a result of her efforts, thalidomide was banned 
    in the United States and Europe.
I mean, it did take a while, but they didn't just give her an award – they _named_ the thing after her when they finally got around to recognize her.

Meanwhile, in places where the market was regulating itself:

    Throughout the world, about 10,000 cases were  
    reported of infants with phocomelia due to
    thalidomide; only 50% of the 10,000 survived.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by tn13 on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:35PM (#13059025)
It only strengthens by argument.

FDA saved people from Thalidomide ? What about over 100K people who lost their life because FDA delayed approval of Provenge and many other life saving drugs ? What about the near monopoly that FDA has granted to EpiPens ? What about millions of Americans who can afford basic healthcare because of FDA's compliance costs and die as a result ?

Just for sample check this : http://www.lifeextension.com/magazine/2010/11/FDA-Delay-of-O...

FDA or market based regulation totally depends on the outcomes and at least for me it is very apparent that market is extremely good at figuring out what works and what not than FDA. Also at significantly lower costs.

>Throughout the world, about 10,000 cases were reported of infants with phocomelia due to thalidomide; only 50% of the 10,000 survived.

It is actually a very good example of how quickly market can detect signals and respond to it. FDA in this case is purely awarded for being slow. FDA has a very poor history of preventing harmful drugs one has to only look at the list of lawsuites after which the drugs ere taken back from market.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by danieltillett on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:31PM (#13058143)
Thalidomide is not a good poster boy for regulation as it was not regulation, but sloth that stopped the approval of thalidomide in the USA. If the company involved had decided to hold off selling it in other countries first the FDA would have approved it.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:30PM (#13058603)
I'm absolutely pro regulation (I'm from europe) but the notion that all regulation is good is just as flawed as the proposition that no regulation would be better. I also agree about the capitalistic basis for regulation, but it really seems to me as if people are substituting the economic asymmetry of the median consumer vs a manufacturer for the liability distribution. That is to say, because the manufacturer has deeper pockets than the consumer (by selling a somewhat dangerous product at a profit) then the manufacturer should bear the bulk of the liability solely because of a greater ability to pay, and regardless of whether the consumer was adequately informed.

Profitability does not automatically imply liability...unless you want all manufacturers to carry total liability insurance for every product they sell and for every product to become significantly more expensive as a result.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by tn13 on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:03PM (#13057573)
> Regulation creates the trust that's essential for any economic activity.

At the moment that seems completely false to me. I don't remember a single time I took any government regulation seriously. For example I take my mechanic's advice about car safety far more seriously than government reports and ratings.

I trust Yelp lot more to chose a doctor for my kid than any government report. Honestly, I dont even care if the doctor actually had a medical degree or not if the yelp reviews and my peer's reviews about that doctor are good enough.

Regulator's role in deceiving public on important issues on the contrary makes me fare more skeptical. Regulator's stand on marijuana, vaping, sugar, fat, mother's milk, ethanol in gas and many others things is often false.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by dpark on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:41PM (#13057812)
> For example I take my mechanic's advice about car safety far more seriously than government reports and ratings.

Why? Your mechanic might have useful insight into the reliability of cars but would have little more visibility into the safety of cars than the average person.

> Honestly, I dont even care if the doctor actually had a medical degree or not if the yelp reviews and my peer's reviews about that doctor are good enough.

I hope your kid is a rhetorical device and not an actual child.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by tn13 on Monday November 28, 2016 @09:14PM (#13060160)
> Your mechanic might have useful insight into the reliability of cars but would have little more visibility into the safety of cars than the average person.

On the contrary he knows more people in real accidents unlike the regulators and sees on regular basis which car did better and worse. He has a clear skin in the game to offer me reliable advice.

> I hope your kid is a rhetorical device and not an actual child.

It is a rhetorical device but I hardly doubt people demand to see their pediatrician's degree certificate.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by dpark on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:32PM (#13060554)
Your mechanic definitely doesn't have sufficient data to make meaningful statements about which cars are safer. Your mechanic might have opinions about which models look better or worse after certain types of accidents but that says nothing about safety. Safety data is gathered by either recording accident outcomes or by simulating accidents. Your mechanic is doing neither of those. In fact the most important outcome is whether a passenger or driver dies, and your mechanic probably never sees those because the cars are generally totaled.

Most people don't demand to see the pediatrician's degree and certifications because the government regulates the industry.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by tn13 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:20AM (#13061022)
You are right. He does not have sufficient data to make meaningful statement about all cars and his knowledge is probably incomplete even about specific cars. But yet what he sees is a real world data far more accurate than what is collected by some agency or simulations performed in the lab. He is a guy with some real skin in the game. I might not ask him if car X is good or bad but most certainly pay heed to him when he says car Y sees a lot of problems.

> Most people don't demand to see the pediatrician's degree and certifications because the government regulates the industry.

People refer to yelp, friends and other known patients before visiting a doctor. Or they rely on a reputable brand of the hospital which has all the incentive to employ good doctors. Government regulation or not people do not rely on mere certificate the doctor has and instead rely on other much more collaborative system to figure out who is a good doctor.

In the absence of government's heavy handed approach of medical regulation the market can perhaps develop a FICO like score for doctors.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by dpark on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:54AM (#13063787)
> He is a guy with some real skin in the game.

Your mechanic has zero skin in the car safety game. He has nothing to gain or lose from giving accurate safety advice. This means he's not financially incentivized to push certain cars but also means he's not incentivized to gather or provide accurate or useful data.

I'm amazed that you're so distrustful of the government that you prefer tarot reading from your mechanic over the recommendations from the agency that literally crashes thousands of cars to gather data on how safe they are. This isn't healthy skepticism. This is blind hate.

> People refer to yelp, friends and other known patients before visiting a doctor.

People generally have no way of knowing the quality of a doctor. They recommend primarily based on whether they like the doctor on a personal level. Which is fine because the medical industry is structured to largely keep incompetent doctors out.

> In the absence of government's heavy handed approach of medical regulation the market can perhaps develop a FICO like score for doctors.

I'm just kind of at a loss here. FICO was such a screwed up system that the government had to step in and regulate it because people were unable to get loans because of bad data and they had no way to find out or fix it. This is hardly a good model for controlling quality in general.

When industries form bodies to self-regulate in the absence of government involvement, it generally doesn't help consumers. It helps the industry. It's also typically called collusion because it's such a harmful practice.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by matt4077 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @08:54AM (#13063008)
This is just insane... You're basically living about 300 years in the past, completely rejection of the scientific method.

Daily life must be fascinating. All these miracles – wireless phones, glowing globes, flying(like off the ground!). Experts are completely useless, so these things must be spiritual creatures, created for the pleasure of "street-smart" people.

I wish there were a way for such people to actually opt out the system they reject.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by tn13 on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @08:09PM (#13076183)
Experts are useless when they don't have skin in the game. A educational expert advising president about education is mostly as ass-hole where as a teacher, principle or private tutor might be far more trust-worthy.

Not one of that invention you list is made by experts working to help people. On the contrary they are a result of spontaneous order created by people pursuing self interest.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by dpark on Thursday December 01, 2016 @09:43AM (#13079615)
The "asshole" advising the president on education is generally a teacher. People don't magically become terrible just because they work for the government.

It's healthy to be skeptical of the government. It's not healthy to always assume malice, because it makes you so biased that you do things like assume your mechanic knows more about the safety of cars than the people whose only job is to determine the safety of cars.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:33PM (#13058626)
I don't remember a single time I took any government regulation seriously.

Well then you're just a foolish person. The absurdity of some regulations doesn't mean that all regulations are absurd - that's a simple fallacy of composition.

I dont even care if the doctor actually had a medical degree or not if the yelp reviews and my peer's reviews about that doctor are good enough.

Yeah sure buddy. Come over next time you have a bad pain and I'll operate for cheap. I have a really high karma score so you know I'm legit.