This is fairly subtle issue, and strawman analogies add nothing of value to the conversation.
It isn't a straw man. The question is how ultra-safe you'd like your society to be. My argument is that we have dangers all around, and some acceptable and reasonable risk must be associated with living. And it's unavoidable to boot. The society that believes that cushioning every corner eliminates daily risks is living a lie.
The trouble is that if you say that banning magnets is reasonable, nobody listens to you when you tell them that banning the sale of automatic weapons should also be. You're crying wolf with the damn magnets. There are bigger fish to fry!
Why are we expected to believe that adults can't tell the difference between candy and powerful magnets just because they're both shiny and metallic-looking? Why are the very clear warnings supplied with the product somehow unreadable in the face of their shiny roundness?