News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by jessriedel on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:24PM (#13056863)
Note: you're making a mistake if you read this story and think "well, at least the system basically works, and the right decision was finally made". The maker of ZenMagnets was tirelessly and bizarrely passionate about overturning this ruling. For every entrepreneur that struggles through a hurdle like this, a dozen more wisely choose to silently forgo developing a similar a product.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by notacoward on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:36PM (#13057394)
For every entrepreneur that struggles through a hurdle like this, how many personal injuries and environmental harms are avoided? You make it sound like regulation exists for no reason or has no upside, but that's a very money-centric POV. From a human POV it's often just as well that some of those startups didn't get off the ground. How many cases of food poisoning or malnutrition were avoided because a dozen Soylent-alikes were - rightly! - told their products were unfit for human consumption?
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by Fordrus on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:04PM (#13057580)
You're committing a critical fallacy here, you're making it sound like this has to be a "virtually non-existent regulation" situation or a circumstance like Zen Magnets went through.

The CPSC and related regulators CAN regulate dangerous stuff without making idiotic wars on toy magnets that undermine their entire existence. Seriously. They can fulfill their entire function, standards of error for mistakes included, without EVER committing such heinously overregulatory acts as this - in fact, it's important to their continued existence that they DO NOT overregulate this badly (because when they do, their opponents gain substantial ammunition to eventually disband/defang them).

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by 762236 on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:43PM (#13058249)
They aren't toy magnets, which is part of the problem: people have internalized that these are toys, which leads to hazardous situations. An educational campaign is surely something that needs to happen.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:16PM (#13057647)
I would agree with you if we were talking about a defective product. But neodymium spheres are not defective, they're just dangerous. I have been interested i this for several years as I own a whole lot of Buckyballs, a previously popular brand of strong magnet sold to the public, which were taken off sale after repeated CPSC objections.

Yes, they're dangerous is you don't follow safety precautions and I would never allow children to play with them. When children visit we make sure the magnets are not accessible - it's our responsibility to think about others' safety. But it's not the responsibility of the magnet manufacturers, as long as they make it clear that their product can be dangerous (and the vendors I've bought from certainly do). The mere fact that something is dangerous is not grounds for taking it off sale, otherwise we should shut down every gas station and hardware store right now.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by goflyapig on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:48PM (#13058276)
>I would agree with you if we were talking about a defective product. But neodymium spheres are not defective, they're just dangerous.

Why make a distinction between things that are dangerous on accident (defective) vs things that are dangerous by design?

>otherwise we should shut down every gas station and hardware store right now.

Every law or regulation needs to balance the risk to society against the benefit to society. This is a toy.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by Grishnakh on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:30PM (#13059007)
So are dildos, but that doesn't mean they need to be made safe for children. These toys were clearly advertised as being for adults only.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:35PM (#13059363)
Why make a distinction between things that are dangerous on accident (defective) vs things that are dangerous by design?

Because many dangerous things have significant utility. Fire is useful for warming your home and cooking food but can also injure or even kill. Water is essential life but you could suffer from hypothermia or drown. These are things that should be obvious to all adults and most children. If you need to have it spelled out to you then your opinions on the economics of safety are not worth very much.

Every law or regulation needs to balance the risk to society against the benefit to society. This is a toy.

It's not a toy just because you say it is, nor are all toys required to be equally safe or not admit any possibility of injury. Really, it's sad that you think such an assertion constitutes a valid argument.

Maybe you think it's 'just a toy' because you can't conceive of any use for it other than mere amusement. That's your problem, not mine.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by goflyapig on Monday November 28, 2016 @09:26PM (#13060237)
> Because many dangerous things have significant utility

Yes, it certainly makes sense to distinguish based on utility, which was the whole point of the second part of my comment, and is why a comparison to gas stations and hardware stores is invalid. Utility is completely orthogonal to "defect vs design".

> It's not a toy just because you say it is

It's a toy because it fits the definition of the word, regardless of how they market it. If it has some purpose other than entertainment, I would love to understand what it is. From my viewpoint, the utility, and therefore the harm caused to society by it being banned, is low. Note how this is different for gasoline and power tools.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by JoeAltmaier on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:44PM (#13059406)
This has gotten out of hand, principally because of this commenter insulting folks out of hand.

Its reasonable to observe social norms, comment on risk vs reward, and suggest different views. Others should not be subject to ridicule and hostile comments for this.

I suggest you take your toy and go home.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by sctb on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:40PM (#13066073)
You're right that personal attacks are not OK here, but we also have the responsibility not to respond in kind.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by DanBC on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:58PM (#13058342)
> This is a toy

This comment is one example of how hard the labelling failed. Buckyballs came with a big label saying "BUCKYBALLS ARE NOT TOYS".

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by geon on Monday November 28, 2016 @04:27PM (#13058584)
You play with them, and they have no other purpose than entertainmenr. Of course they are toys. Just not suitable for children.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by toss1 on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:09PM (#13057609)
Yes, many regulations exist for good reason and have significant upsides.

However, it's false to say that EVERY individual regulation meets these criteria. As TFA pointed out, these objects are far less hazardous than firearms, fireworks, automobiles, and even balloons (the leading cause of child suffocation, and for whic labeling is required), but because they are novel the CPSC decided to slap them with an absolute ban, which is stronger regulation than any of the other products listed above and thousands of others.

This was a very badly considered and executed regulation, and the judge acted rightly. FWIW, I don't think anyone is saying what you imply, that all regulations are baseless and bad.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by jessriedel on Monday November 28, 2016 @05:14PM (#13058882)
> You make it sound like regulation exists for no reason or has no upside

What exactly did I say that made it sound like that?

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by openclosed on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:31PM (#13056918)
What makes you say bizarrely?

It seems normal to pursue something that could result in economic benefit, if you have the means to do so. And if there's a larger principle at stake, all the more reason.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by jessriedel on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:39PM (#13056972)
I used "bizarre" based on the tone of the guys writing. Read some of the older stuff he's written about it; it's been going on for years. He cares about this a lot more than most people who suffer from these sorts of regulation. It's not clear to me that he actually ended up with an economic benefit to justify the time he spent on it.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by Tempest1981 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:12AM (#13061415)
So "surprisingly passionate"?
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by michaelt on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:56PM (#13057117)
A frequent narrative I hear on HN is that going to court is ruinously expensive, emotionally taxing, wildly uncertain even if you're completely in the right, and so slow any victory is almost certain to be Pyrrhic.

Someone who believes that narrative would have expected this guy to lose, pay six figures in legal fees, have a mental breakdown, and the judgement to only come in five years after his magnet company closed down because they couldn't sell their only product.

Personally I don't have enough experience to know whether the US legal system really works that way.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:41PM (#13059386)
I think that's actually an accurate characterization of the legal system. I highly recommend this book if you're interested: https://www.amazon.com/Adversarial-Legalism-American-Way-Law...
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by bitJericho on Monday November 28, 2016 @06:01PM (#13059188)
My first hand experience is it works exactly that way.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by ocdtrekkie on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:36PM (#13056957)
The CPSC successfully drove every other company in this product category out of business. For any CEO in this position, it honestly bears question whether fighting a seemingly unwinnable battle (they claim they're the first to win such a battle in over 20 years) is going to end up eventually allowing you to turn a profit, or if your best bet is to close up shop and enter a different business entirely.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:46PM (#13057835)
It's bizarre in that he went to great lengths to prove a point when there were much easier ways to make more money in the same period. Most people would not be willing to spend as much money on proving the point but would rather use it to produce something less controversial.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by matt4077 on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:31PM (#13056927)
If, however, you think "too bad there are dozens of entrepreneurs that fail at hurdles like these", make sure to remember: for every entrepreneur that encounters such Kafkaesque situations, there are thousands that never run into any problems with bureaucracy that can't be solved with a phone call or a two-page form.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by jessriedel on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:43PM (#13056999)
The large, economy-wide negative impact of regulation are well established by academics. You can think the benefits are worth the cost, but you can't think the costs are small.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mejari on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:53PM (#13057090)
>The large, economy-wide negative impact of regulation are well established by academics.

That sounds like an easily made, hard to back up claim.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mamurphy on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:39PM (#13057414)
"Regulations are very costly (in a large, economy-wide way)," to me, sounded like an almost-self-evident, incredibly easy to back up claim. 15 seconds with Google confirmed that initial assessment.

http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic...

"The Costs and Benefits of Regulation: Review and Synthesis" RW Hahn, Yale Journal of Regulation, Volume 8, Issue 1, Article 9, 1991

The above link was the first Google result for (economy-wide costs of regulations journal) for me, and Google notes that it is cited by hundreds of other articles. The first 10 results all seemed to similarly explain that regulations are costly.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by cbsmith on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:26PM (#13057715)
That paper actually points out that costs have been widely overestimated. It also points out that estimating the costs is very difficult and a lot of estimates out there are pretty hand wavy and/or just made up.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by jessriedel on Monday November 28, 2016 @09:36PM (#13060295)
It also says "Overall, they find that the efficiency cost due to economic regulation is large and that the benefit from social regulation is positive but small."
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by cbsmith on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @05:42AM (#13069709)
Note the first part is "economic regulation" and the second part is "social regulation".
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mejari on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:47PM (#13057472)
Having a cost and having a "large, economy-wide negative impact" are very different things.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by acedinlowball on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:02PM (#13057929)
Do you think you can explain why someone might think they aren't different things? I'm not sure you can...
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mejari on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:19PM (#13058054)
Geez, at least give me a chance before you decide what I can't do.

The difference is pretty basic: Having a "negative impact" requires value-judgement, having a cost does not. In terms of economics it requires a broad view of the entire economy, whereas a cost can be directly assigned to a single event or series of events.

Saying that a regulation has a cost is saying that it requires some expenditure to implement/maintain. Saying it has a negative impact is saying that the expenditure to implement/maintain that regulation outweighs the as-yet-in-this-discussion undefined benefits of the regulation in question.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mamurphy on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:16PM (#13057648)
Why did you feel the need to reply with this sentence? How does it advance our conversation whatsoever? You replied saying

>Having a cost and having a "large, economy-wide negative impact" are very different things.

Is a large cost not a large negative impact? Are regulations by the federal government not economy-wide? Are you making any discernible point that couldn't have been expressed by "NUH UH, I'M STILL RIGHT LALALALA!"?

To pick a random example: The article doesn't say it costs shoppers in Des Moines $4,029 per year due to milk-market regulations. It costs US citizens somewhere between $500 million and $2.1 billion per year - in 1991.

The journal article I linked is literally about the large, economy-wide costs of regulations. Your response is a non-sequitor.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:43PM (#13057819)
You have not demonstrated a net negative cost. In fact, I wonder if you even read the abstract, which states in pertinent part: [Authors] find that previous estimates of the costs of economic regulation probably overstated the true costs by failing to distinguish between transfer payments and net changes in economic efficiency [...] Overall, they find that the efficiency cost due to economic regulation is large and that the benefit from social regulation is positive but small. Their study also finds a huge variation in estimates of the costs and benefits ofparticular regulatory policies, particularly in the transportation sector and in environmental protection. This variation indicates that most estimates may be merely "guesstimates."

Going with your random example plucked from the article... [Milk market regulations] cost US citizens somewhere between $500 million and $2.1 billion per year - in 1991.

Besides the wild variation, so what? That number is meaningless without the context of the size of the milk market as a whole which would allow us to assess the scope of the burden, not to mention some estimate of the likely economic cost of an unregulated milk marketplace (eg economic losses due to illness from disease).

Why do you think it's impressive to pull out a big number like this without any context? It's ridiculous. If we're going to go with cherry-picking argument of this type, I can't help noticing that Americans love milk and almost every American refrigerator I'e ever seen has an open container of milk. So since we're talking about the US as a whole in your example, and there were ~250m Americans in 1991, it seems like these regulations imposed a cost of between $2 and $8 that year on every American...which doesn't sound like all that much to pay for a year of knowing the milk you enjoy is safe to consume. MY household spends about $7-800 a year on dairy products, so back in 1991, and adjusting very generously for inflation, we might have spent $200 to consume the same amount of milk. Using the worst-case number from your paper, positing an upper regulatory burden for every American of $8 and doubling it to represent the two people in my household, maybe $16 of that $200 consisted of regulatory costs. So the worst-case scenario is that regulation drove up the cost of milk by 8%, which doesn't sound like that bad of a trade.

Since I've done all the work here so far perhaps you'd like to estimate the benefits of reliably safe milk in terms of avoided medical costs from dairy-borne pathogens.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mejari on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:03PM (#13057934)
>Why did you feel the need to reply with this sentence? How does it advance our conversation whatsoever?

Because you replied with a link to something that did not further the point under discussion.

>Is a large cost not a large negative impact?

No, it is not.

>The journal article I linked is literally about the large, economy-wide costs of regulations.

And it appears to mostly disagree with the point you are trying to make.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by gertef on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:49PM (#13057488)
regulations are obviously costly, benefits are obviously great. the important hard question is the net.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mamurphy on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:18PM (#13057655)
>regulations are obviously costly, benefits are obviously great. the important hard question is the net.

Well of course, but the comment I responded to questioned the assertion that there is a large, economy-wide cost.

Is the benefit of (cleaner air/safer highways/magnet-free-toys) worth the cost? That's what the debate ought to be about. But first we all have to agree that there is a cost being paid.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by mejari on Monday November 28, 2016 @03:04PM (#13057940)
>Well of course, but the comment I responded to questioned the assertion that there is a large, economy-wide cost.

No, I did not. The comment I replied to implied a net-negative cost.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:24PM (#13057700)
Finding a citation isn't the same as forming an argument. A 25 year old article is also not a very impressive comeback considering that there has been a lot of new research in economics and in computational analytics over that period. Try harder.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by gwbas1c on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:14PM (#13057634)
When regulation is used by incumbent businesses to block competition, yes.

When regulation is used to protect people from being taken advantage of, then the benefits are well worth the cost.

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by anigbrowl on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:22PM (#13057679)
The costs lie on a distribution and most of the time they are small when broken out. It's dishonest to cite huge numbers from aggregated costs or cherry-pick costs from highly-regulated industries like pharma or chemistry where the regulatory burden is high due to substantially elevated risk.
Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by kefka on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:46PM (#13057025)
An "some form" means some faceless bureaucrat fuckhead, who's having a lousy day (after reading my comment!) rubber-stamps "NOPE".... or is just lost.

These are barriers to trade. And we got to this place with death by a thousand regulation cuts. Can't do this. Can't do that. Cant do this on that day while doing that instead of this, without willing out volumes of forms. And you wonder why compliance costs are stupid high?

(Don't get me wrong, I hold to a mixture of communism and capitalism - I think something like GNU can be done for nearly everything, but there's room for making money as well. I just categorically disagree with the volume of regulations. It makes people criminals via incapability of understanding the law.)

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by matt4077 on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:18PM (#13057284)
Well, considering your username, I'm sure you may end up in those Kafkaesque situations more than usual...

But, seriously: This nightmare is one of the stories we tell each other. But, for most companies, it's just not true.

I've started four or five companies. Mostly software, one that sells actual (government-certified organic) food, one that mostly worked for governments (including the defense sector). In all that time, I've never felt like regulation prevented me from doing anything. Once or twice, I had to submit some form that I thought was overkill. But in fact I doubt there was ever a year where I spend more than two or three days net on government bureaucracy.

I know that the situation may be different for construction or airplane startups (at least I hope it is). But this sort of hyperbole is just a lie that doesn't improve by repetition.

If anything, I've been surprised by how little regulation there sometimes is. Look at AirBnB or Uber or drones: Who would've though that you could (for a time) fly a model airplane in Heathrow's final approach corridor and only get a "we're looking into it and engaging in a dialog with all interested parties" as a reply?

Re:Magnet Ban Cleared by ashark on Monday November 28, 2016 @12:59PM (#13057137)
OTOH too little regulation can easily mean no-one trusting a brand they don't recognize as large and well-established to even reach the standard of not killing them, let alone being any good.

Personally I'm already there with lots of stuff. I'm aware that it's letting certain companies collect rents, but it's generally not worth my time and the extra risk to track down another brand that might be acceptably reliable and safe, assuming they haven't decided to burn whatever little reputation they've built up for some short-term profit by swapping their once-decent product for crap while keeping the price and model info the same after all the reviews I read were written.

That's also a barrier to entry. Economies are tricky things :-/