Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures
by lisper on Saturday November 26, 2016 @09:18PM
(#13047320)
> the much more likely case is not a Mad Max scenario
I'd say Mad Max is the worst case. Possible, but certainly not inevitable. How likely it is depends on what we choose to do (or not do). But we have to stop talking about turning Earth into Venus or destroying all life or even humans going extinct. None of those are going to happen.
> The worst case scenario is we see innocent people needlessly die due to the actions of other people
The worst case scenario is the collapse of modern technological civilization with the resulting deaths of billions of innocent people. The worst case is really, really bad. So arguments like this:
> we simply don't know what we're doing when it comes to global climate science
don't carry a lot of weight with me. It's true that there is a lot of uncertainty. But that uncertainty cuts both ways. We might be erring in either direction, and the consequences of getting this wrong are very, very serious. So we ought to err on the conservative side. Because the only way to know for sure whether the worst case is possible is to actually make it happen.
> While of course anything is possible, can you link me to scientific evidence that this will happen.
No, of course not. But I can probably find some papers that show that it's possible.
I'd say Mad Max is the worst case. Possible, but certainly not inevitable. How likely it is depends on what we choose to do (or not do). But we have to stop talking about turning Earth into Venus or destroying all life or even humans going extinct. None of those are going to happen.
> The worst case scenario is we see innocent people needlessly die due to the actions of other people
The worst case scenario is the collapse of modern technological civilization with the resulting deaths of billions of innocent people. The worst case is really, really bad. So arguments like this:
> we simply don't know what we're doing when it comes to global climate science
don't carry a lot of weight with me. It's true that there is a lot of uncertainty. But that uncertainty cuts both ways. We might be erring in either direction, and the consequences of getting this wrong are very, very serious. So we ought to err on the conservative side. Because the only way to know for sure whether the worst case is possible is to actually make it happen.
> While of course anything is possible, can you link me to scientific evidence that this will happen.
No, of course not. But I can probably find some papers that show that it's possible.