News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Erlang vs node.js by jerf on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:48AM (#1304599)
"Apparently there is no built in method to wait on results. There were promisses but they were removed."

Because if you do that, the whole value proposition of Node.js completely falls apart. Now you've blocked the entire system waiting for your result. You might as well be programming in any other blocking language (all of which have Node.js-like libraries, by the way). This is what you get when you try to build concurrency on top of a language fundamentally built on non-concurrent primitives.

Consider going pure Erlang, which does work exactly the way you are looking for it to work. You call a function, which passes around messages and gets the result for you, and the result comes back along the function call, and all the not-blocking is handled by the Erlang VM, totally transparently. (Oh, and you get OTP, which if your server is non-trivial you really need, even if you don't know it yet. And transparent multi-proc support, easy clustering support, couple of other things that Node.js may someday have with great, great, great, great effort and even then they'll still be hacks unless they fundamentally change Javascript to basically become Erlang.)

Node.js is probably going to end up being a huge argument in favor of Erlang, because I suspect you will not be the last to encounter this problem in Node.js. It is absolutely inevitable that any significant application trying to be built in Node.js must collapse into a mess of callbacks and closures that will be very difficult to trace through. That's how it's designed. Any attempt to hack around this will have its own issues with gross hacks or difficulties with branching.

I really don't see Node.js being a success in the long term. It is built on a foundation that is not up to the task. Building a really big Node.js app would be a nightmare, and the reasons why are not going to come out of the foundation easily, if at all.

Here, let me give you an example with my work system I'm building. I have a single function which fans out an RPC request to multiple systems, collates the results with a timeout, and returns the results to the caller (or optionally calls some other code at the end, in the handler process). The initiator does not set up a callback, it just makes a call. The fanout mechanism does not set up a weird time-sliced mechanism to send out the calls, it just does it. There's some callbacks for handling whether it gets an error or a result coming back, which is pretty normal, and note, I don't have to contort around whether those callbacks may themselves want to do something over the network, they're just simple, one-layer callbacks that I would have implemented as callbacks in any language. (Imagine how you'd do that in an event-based system, deal with a response callback that may itself want to do a callback chain. It's perfectly feasible, I can easily see how to do it, but I sure as hell don't want to actually try to code it.) In Erlang, this is very natural; a function call that behind the scenes spawns a process that does what it says and says what it does, and works quite well. In an event-based system, this simple bit of functionality would be a callback explosion. I count a dozen, easily, and it would probably double if I really tried to do it. And that's not my whole system, either, it's just one bit. The multiplicative complexity explosion that occurs with Node.js's approach just isn't feasible.

(Note Erlang handles "events" quite well, indeed, it's a native paradigm for many parts of the system; what it doesn't have is the multiplicative explosion of manually-created event handlers caused by offloading the scheduling onto the programmer.)

Re:Erlang vs node.js by Rauchg on Thursday April 29, 2010 @10:58AM (#1304642)
re: promises/chaining

Check out:

http://github.com/rsms/node-promise

http://github.com/creationix/step

http://github.com/creationix/do

Did the value proposition of node fall apart?

.

re: multi-proc support

From www.nodejs.org architecture design statement:

"But what about multiple-processor concurrency? Threads are necessary to scale programs to multi-core computers. Processes are necessary to scale to multi-core computers, not memory-sharing threads. The fundamentals of scalable systems are fast networking and non-blocking design—the rest is message passing. In future versions, Node will be able to fork new processes (using the Web Workers API ), but this is something that fits well into the current design."

Re:Erlang vs node.js by jerf on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:09AM (#1304682)
"re: promises/chaining"

Yup, exactly what I was expecting to see. Not even close to matching Erlang. You're still chopping up your code pretty grotesquely, and you're going to rapidly find out that while that made a few things you were used to doing work well, when you want to take the next step of logical flow that stuff is going to stick in your craw. It's a fairly normal abstraction, in that for the price of making one thing easy it's going to make other things harder.

I implemented that for myself in browser-side javascript years ago, so I actually do know what I'm talking about. (All 3 are really the same basic approach, and it's the only basic approach there is.) It's a little more convenient than the alternative, but it only lightly brushes over a couple of the pointy bits of this approach, and leaves quite a lot of the rest of them still in your face.

" Threads are necessary to scale programs to multi-core computers. Processes are necessary to scale to multi-core computers, not memory-sharing threads. The fundamentals of scalable systems are fast networking and non-blocking design—the rest is message passing. In future versions, Node will be able to fork new processes (using the Web Workers API ), but this is something that fits well into the current design."

I don't have to do anything in Erlang to get multi-processor support. I just run the VM. Rationalizations about why multi-process is hard and it's OK that we don't have it, we don't really need it are irrelevant, I have it in hand. And if you're not familiar with Erlang, you may need to know what it's definition of "process" is: An "Erlang process" is basically a thread, but has process-like isolation from other threads, which is where the word "process" comes in. Erlang essentially automatically runs things in the most-optimized thread-pooling system you've ever seen, and I don't have to think about it. Are you going to be able to spawn off a few ten thousand Web Workers without worrying about the resource usage? (Or hundred thousands? ... or millions?) I'd be surprised. It might be possible, but I'd be surprised.

Bear in mind I'm coming at this as a near-decade user of Javascript and a multi-year professional user of Erlang. I am not unfamiliar with the languages. You can not match Erlang in Javascript, not even with web workers. You can smooth things around, but all you'll get is a yet-more beguiling slide into complexity if you try to do anything at a large scale. (You'd honestly be better off if you hit the limits of Node.js sooner, rather than later.)

Re:Erlang vs node.js by davidw on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:16AM (#1304703)
Part of my point in the article is that, while node.js is not as good as Erlang, it may be "good enough" for a great many web/network things where Erlang might be considered for its strengths. It's sort of a 'disruptive innovation' situation.
Re:Erlang vs node.js by jerf on Thursday April 29, 2010 @11:28AM (#1304746)
And that's fine. I rather expect you're totally correct in terms of describing what's going to actually happen; Erlang is a non-Algol language and while that's slowly becoming more respectable we've got a long ways to go before it is considered as anything but a negative by the vast bulk of programmers.

It's just that I've actually been down this path a few times with other apps and I feel a responsibility to raise a flag and point out that all applications tend to grow and building with a base that will cause your code to explode in complexity as you tend to grow is not the best plan, but I also know that this is very firmly in the class of things people have to learn for themselves. And the cute little proxies and such aren't bad, it's surprisingly hard to guarantee your app stays in the class of "cute little".

One of my other work apps is actually something built on the Perl wrapper around glib, using its event library, because I ended up having no choice for other reasons (was wrapping a C library and local political concerns wrote Erlang out). And ye gods, the mess, the mess, and the bugs, the bugs. Event chains four or five layers deep in callbacks (multistage login processes being wrapped by other multistage login processes, oi). It's the same exact organizational pattern as Node.js, and it just doesn't scale, even when you know what you're doing. Every trick I know brought to bear to simplify and improve (plugins, simulated generators with goto at a couple points, equivalents to the func chaining hack linked above), but you just can't overcome the weakness of the primitives.

Re:Erlang vs node.js by akkartik on Thursday April 29, 2010 @06:10PM (#1306249)
I read your comments on node.js with interest, but I object to being called an 'algol-like' programmer just because I can't deal with erlang.

I work with haskell and lisp just fine, and I can find my way around monads, closures and continuations. It's just the prolog syntax I can't get past.

That and a million little niggles. How do you quit from erl, anyway? Is there a faster way than C-g C-c a? [update: argh, C-\ has thwarted me for years. http://www.erlang.org/faq/getting_started.html It's hard to describe why - it's always obvious in hindsight - but erlang has been extremely painful to learn. I have no trouble with documentation and man pages, but with erlang it seems there's always one more place to check.]

I can't wait for lfe to mature.

Re:Erlang vs node.js by jerf on Wednesday May 05, 2010 @01:44PM (#1321877)
Sorry, I only saw this much later. When I say that Erlang is non-Algol, it is not a criticism of a given programmer. It is a criticism of the industry as a whole, that nothing that looks like Algol can succeed anytime soon.

Erlang is full of frustrating quirks and in other contexts you can find me complaining about them and how they don't all go away when you get used to them. (; , . is just plain BS.)