News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I don’t belong in tech by pjmorris on Saturday November 26, 2016 @02:18PM (#13045390)
> Tech is big, no need to quit all of it.

“Well if no one out there understands, start your own revolution and cut out the middle man” - Billy Bragg, Waiting for the Great Leap Forwards

Bragg was writing about the tension between being a musician and being a political activist rather than the tension between problem understanding and problem solving, but the tension seems to be everywhere. I've got a friend who was frustrated about how little his PhD had to do with philosophy because there was no time for that, only time to publish. Alan Kay said something of the ilk in the epic Ask HN thread a few months ago, referring to how hard it's been to get funding to do good research for something like the last 35 years or so. Hopefully the author can find her 'birds of a feather', it's not like we lack problems that need understanding.

Re:I don’t belong in tech by nathan_f77 on Saturday November 26, 2016 @03:17PM (#13045624)
> I've got a friend who was frustrated about how little his PhD had to do with philosophy because there was no time for that, only time to publish.

I don't understand. He studied philosophy but ended up writing a thesis that was only tangentially related to the field?

Or he assumed that "Doctor of Philosophy" was related to the field of philosophy, and was disappointed that he couldn't talk about Plato while writing about physics?

Re:I don’t belong in tech by pjmorris on Saturday November 26, 2016 @03:33PM (#13045699)
More like the later, but less extreme. Disappointed that there wasn't time to talk about the philosophical aspects of computer science in a degree named `Doctor of Philosophy'.
Re:I don’t belong in tech by nathan_f77 on Saturday November 26, 2016 @04:03PM (#13045840)
Oh, well that's not really what "Doctor of Philosophy" means. It comes from the same Greek word, which means "love of wisdom", but it's unrelated the field of philosophy.

I also think the philosophy of computer science is very interesting, though. I just saw that Oxford offers a course that combines computer science and philosophy: https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses-listin...

Re:I don’t belong in tech by pjmorris on Saturday November 26, 2016 @04:11PM (#13045879)
Well, I think it's the 'love of wisdom' angle that I saw in my friend's frustration and the article author's distinction between problem understanding and problem solving. I think there's a place for knowledge for knowledge's sake, akin to Hardy's belief that mathematics is worth pursuing for its own sake, not just its applications.
Re:I don’t belong in tech by jhanschoo on Saturday November 26, 2016 @06:25PM (#13046631)
Actually, whereas the word literally means that, the use of the word philosophy to mean a disciplined investigation into questions actually predates even Plato's Academy.

The reason why academic titles have the word philosophy in them is because modern investigations have developed from the philosophical tradition.

For example, philosophers may have a question, "what is value?", or "what is the nature of the world?", born out of the philosophical tradition.

Then, after sufficient discussion and philosophical investigation, they figure out that certain methods, approaches to answering these questions, are very fertile and lead to informative answers, e.g. value as a real-valued mathematical measure, or the nature of the world as a generalization of empirical observation.

Such methods may prove to be so fertile that you may have academics spending decades or centuries investigating the implications of that method. Hence you have economics and philosophy.

Re:I don’t belong in tech by hprotagonist on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:54PM (#13066897)
it also has to do with the fact that the title of the degree predates the differentiation of many of the sciences. Newton, for example, would not have described himself as a physicist because that word didn't yet exist. (it was first coined, per the OED, in 1840.) He was a natural philosopher, which meant he thought Aristotle could be wrong and you could prove that.