News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:30PM (#13039994)
Begging the question; economics is not a physical science where you can run A/B tests on an economy and find results. It's a social study, mostly. As someone who studied it for years, institutionally and on my own, I can tell you that economists do not agree on any basic laws except that people have a long list of wants and that not all of them can be satisfied.

Many economists are questioning their 101s lately. Look closely in the various journals and you'll see evidence of that, both explicitly and implicitly.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by BurningFrog on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:23PM (#13040627)
> economics is not a physical science where you can run A/B tests on an economy and find results

The is broadly true of Macro Economics. This might even be impossible as a science, since the object of study (world economy and markets) is aware of its findings, and adapts around them.

Micro Economics, or "Price Theory" as it maybe should be called, is OTOH a very powerful science that gives deep and counter intuitive insights into how the world works.

It is also largely ignore by decision makers :)

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by tomp on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:57PM (#13041070)
Are you sure about microeconomics? AFAIK, only recently have economists started to use behavioral economics (psychology & game theory) to logically explain empirical behaviours that were previously thought of as irrational. It doesn't really seem to be a solved problem.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by BurningFrog on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:21PM (#13041524)
I'm not a real economist, just a really interested amateur.

My impression is that "behavioral" economics is a promising field that can help explain some unusual phenomena. But it doesn't change the solid core of the science.

I think it gets talked about like that sometimes by people who don't like the implications of the established science. Much like what happens with Climate Change and Evolution when any seemingly contradictory study appears.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:25PM (#13040645)
I love you. :)

Seriously, though, your econ mind is on the same track as mine. "Economics" is a pretty broad brush, and it's difficult engaging in meaningful discussion.

You make a great point: The "economic system" is conscious and reacts/adapts to internal and external changes, which changes the rules, and the meta rules, and the meta meta meta....

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:02PM (#13041459)
Can't edit my original comment – sorry about the 'I love you', that's a bit over the top. I might've had a drink earlier. ;)
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by BurningFrog on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:23PM (#13041533)
I know you can find love in unlikely places, but I never thought it would find me in the comment section!
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by rubberstamp on Saturday November 26, 2016 @12:12PM (#13044660)
Micro economics is not science either as people are conscious and adapts(find loopholes) around them whenever its possible to do so.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by BurningFrog on Saturday November 26, 2016 @02:30PM (#13045430)
Got any examples?

If we're talking about supply and demand, price elasticity, and things like that, I can't think of any loopholes. Knowing how these things work only makes people make more informed decisions.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by rubberstamp on Saturday November 26, 2016 @09:22PM (#13047344)
Take the pricing of anything. Its greed pricing vs how much greed is tolerated. Take fish for example. In our local market prices basically increase roughly every 2 or 3 weeks. Sellers quote high when they are not desperate for money. They don't care if it doesn't sell. Now they may lie to other sellers that they sold at higher price and then others try their luck at pushing price high. Sales may be down for initial two three days but then people start buying at higher price. Fish supply hasn't changed, cost of catching it haven't changed cost of living didn't change, wages earned by buyers didn't change.

That is pure capitalism at play as it is a free market without government regulations.

Similarly some drugs that are priced at crazy multiples of real cost to produce it(including RnD and healthy profit) by the likes of martin shkreli.

So its basically how much the individuals in an economy values money. When the seller quotes high and I as a buyer has truck load of money, I wouldn't even bother to bargain. When I don't have cash, I try to bargain it to the bottom levels and sellers would probably not even be able to cover their cost.

Pricing that varies over the day in ecommerce websites is another example. Time during which people are more likely to rush into buying, things are priced high.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by snrplfth on Sunday November 27, 2016 @12:23AM (#13047866)
These examples don't actually disprove anything about microeconomics though.

Your example of the fish markets is just a good example of the fact that people have varying marginal utilities of money. Of course people try to get the highest price they can get - taking into account, of course, the time they'll be receiving the money. Obviously people will see if they can raise the price, but they're still in competition with other sellers; the price cannot be raised indefinitely. And it's not always clear whether other factors have changed - things like fish supply and catching are notoriously dependent on the weather, demand for fish varies seasonally and with changing fashions; it's a perishable good with not-super-fungible markets - maybe the prices know something about fish that you don't.

You give the example of super-high pricing for drugs such as the Daraprim case with Martin Shkreli. Note that this market is overseen and hugely, hugely regulated by the FDA, which imposes very lengthy and costly approval processes on drugs (even different manufacturers of off-patent "generics".) More generally, these drugs are on-patent - both of these situations are a de-facto monopoly that grants exactly the kind of economic rents that microeconomics predicts.

Ecommerce pricing also doesn't disprove anything. You could, for example, explain this by other factors, such as that ecommerce warehouses and logistics chains are capacity-limited, so "surge pricing" would make good sense to smooth demand peaks. But that's besides the point, really, because microeconomics would absolutely predict that if people, on average, have a preference for shopping at a particular time, then a seller may attempt to capture this preference in the price. This isn't done in brick-and-mortar retail, since changing the prices hourly would be a huge hassle. But in ecommerce, it's easy, so prices modulate with demand. And stores have always changed their prices over time, it's just that the internet makes it easy to go for a smaller granularity.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by srtjstjsj on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:06PM (#13041474)
what kind of insights?
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by Pyxl101 on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:53PM (#13040127)
Can you give one (preferably two) specific examples of respected economists who are questioning 101 level econ principles?

I've studied economics at the college level. I follow economics news and am not aware of economists questioning 101 level principles. Many of these are relatively simple and intuitively obvious ones (once you wrap your head around them), much like 101 level maths.

Consequently I am inclined to disbelieve the claim that economists are questioning econ 101 principles, unless you can provide some examples. More than one example would be most convincing since you're claiming this is a general trend. Journal article links would be appreciated.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by cdavid on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:22PM (#13040273)
(I am not an economist, never took a class in economics, but am interested in the field and like to read about it, so talke all of this w/ a grain of salt)

It is not so much about questioning economics 101 principles as much as questioning their validity in the various economies. Taking the example of comparative advantage and more general trade theory, there are well known, respected economists (e.g. D. Rodrik) who have argued against the scope of their validity.

There also seems to be a debate about how 101 is taught in schools, see e.g. [1].

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/05/13/...

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:41PM (#13040376)
You're right, it's a larger question of validity in these nuances. I knew I'd get in trouble saying "101", but I hope people will read that in a sympathetic light. (Ha!)
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:36PM (#13040350)
Please accept my apologies: I'm taking a Mary Poppins approach by "not explaining anything." We're all capable of looking for examples that'll confirm our own suspicions; an attempt at confirming or disconfirming what I've blurted out above can be an exercise for the diligent reader.

I want to push back on the idea that economics is a way to divinate the truth of how to generate and share happiness. It's a piece of the puzzle, but a very small one.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by carsongross on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:39PM (#13041221)
I think Steve keen is worth reading.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by cperciva on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:40PM (#13040056)
"Trade and exploiting comparative advantages yields greater utility" is about as hard a law as any.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:35PM (#13040702)
If the law stands in isolation. But there are more questions that arise. To whom? For how long? In which way? Etc. etc.

The side effects must be investigated because that's largely where we are in the public discourse right now. We're in a big adjustment period. We're learning about consequences; good and bad.

Reminds me of Keyne's famous long-run quote.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by lomnakkus on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:49PM (#13041037)
Caveat: The interests must align[1]. (See: Principal Agent Problem.)

[1] Which they, in actual fact, very seldom do.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by daptaq on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:56PM (#13040142)
Not if you ask marxist-economists...
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by VodkaHaze on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:33PM (#13040333)
Yes, and we should ask Lysenkoists about effective growing of crops.

Marx contributed massively to sociology. He contributed nothing of note to economics that's really relevant to this day (not that his effort was not commendable). Sticking to orthodox marxist economics in 2016 is more dogma than science.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by youdontknowtho on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:38PM (#13040723)
That wasn't the point. The point is that the "laws" of economics are the same rigorous laws of physics.

Markets aren't forces of nature. That's propaganda.

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by cwyers on Friday November 25, 2016 @06:47PM (#13040764)
Citing economic theory that has been discredited as evidence that economics is not a science makes about as much sense as citing Ptolemy's Geocentric model as evidence that astronomy isn't a science.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by youdontknowtho on Saturday November 26, 2016 @09:01AM (#13043516)
Again. No one need to prove that economics isn't the same kind of science as physics. so that guy made a bad analogy. don't care.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by thesagan on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:50PM (#13040407)
Marx's contributions to sociology are definitely relevant today, even if they're not in vogue. Even if they're wrong. This is human behavior we're talking about, and people have memories that they act upon.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by cperciva on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:02PM (#13040188)
And if you ask biblical literalists, they'll tell you that there was no big bang but the world was instead created in six days. There are always some people with counterfactual beliefs.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by Avshalom on Friday November 25, 2016 @07:28PM (#13040949)
Being a happy Subaru owner I'm rather glad Japan ignored comparative advantage.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by pdonis on Friday November 25, 2016 @09:52PM (#13041426)
> I'm rather glad Japan ignored comparative advantage.

They did? How so?

Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by WalterBright on Friday November 25, 2016 @05:18PM (#13040252)
Most (all?) bad economic policies come from denial of economics 101. For example, fixed currency exchange rates. And, of course, wage and price controls.
Re:What if jobs are not the solution but the problem? by srtjstjsj on Friday November 25, 2016 @10:10PM (#13041487)
No, economic policies come from observation that policies are sociological. Economics tells us what is, not what is desirable. Policies are applied economics, intended to distribute value in unnatural but desirable ways. Price controls and other "bad" economic policies are akin to a rocket ship's gravity controls that generate huge amounts of entropy to lift a metal box off the ground: They sacrifice some measure of global optimality in exchange for local improvements.