> I don't hide what I do IRL
So you change your clothes, bathe, go to the toilet and have sex in full view of others? Or, more pertinently, would be happy to be legally required to do so?The closest analogy I think that's reasonable on say your "have sex in full view of others" that's pertinent is that the government could overhear me talking to someone about sex and would record that I had talked to someone about sex. Now for an abuser that might be an issue, but for me it's not.
Take a step back. What's your best argument to convince me gov access [by warrant] to a list of domains I've visited - where I haven't used a VPN, or other obscuring method - means I'm giving up my civil liberties in a way that will have a damaging impact on me?
I can see it can for a small portion of society, a lot of [non-petty] criminals. I can see it might for political dissidents in a country lacking rule of law; UK isn't perfect in that regard but it's close to having a fully independent judiciary and a fully working rule of law.
[FWIW I wouldn't vote for such a law, but I'm yet to be convinced by the arguments I've seen, primarily because they are so outlandishly hyperbolic.]
This proves that the government is willing to selectively present out of context information from someone's browsing history in court in order to further their agenda. If you believe every employee at all 49 agencies who have access to this data will never misuse it, well, you're more trusting than me.
And I haven't even touched on any of those agencies being the conduit of leaked information, and the ramifications of that. If the NSA can't even keep a lid on confidential information when it's staffed with some of the most experienced and intelligent techs in the world, what hope does the Department for Work and Pensions have?
As an undesirable, I (as a bureaucrat hungry for power) might uninvite you and yours from my college, business, bank loan, job offer, or I might simply charge you more for goods or services. Given the power, I can make your life hell for reasons you'll never know and have no redress to challenge.
In 1870s to 1960s America these kinds of off-the-book practices were called 'Jim Crow', intended to repress minorities and especially blacks from the civil rights and protections that were theirs by law. If our 21st century government regresses to the same state the FBI did under Hoover -- not inconceivable under Trump, since it already has occurred under Obama as he allowed CIA and NSA to escape oversight from congress or the press and hide from their abuses of constitutional law -- the likelihood of history repeating itself using domestic espionage has become almost a certainty.
If you still have doubts about the threat to everyone from unlimited domestic surveillance to big and small, innocent and guilty, then reread Orwell's 1984. And never forget that EVERYONE is part of some minority that will become unpopular eventually.
I doubt it.
For example, in the US, most people are not afraid to share their political beliefs. This is because, in the US, it isn't common to be harmed or even killed for your beliefs. This is not true in every country or even for every part of the US. So being able to keep your political views a secret is important. In a world where this is not possible it can quickly become dangerous to hold the "wrong beliefs" publicly.
Do you believe you only uphold the "right beliefs"? And if so - are you 100% certain those beliefs will never turn into the "wrong beliefs" to have? If you answer "no" to either question then privacy should be important to you.
If I uphold "wrong belief", last thing I want to is to make it secret. The more people know about it, the more popular it is, the more people understand it, more chance for it to be not 'wrong' anymore.
>If I uphold "wrong belief", last thing I want to is to make it secret. The more people know about it, the more popular it is, the more people understand it, more chance for it to be not 'wrong' anymore.
Oh, I agree with this! But I also think it is a personal choice if someone wishes to strongly advocate for their beliefs - with all the repercussions that may follow - or if they would rather privately hold their beliefs without fear of repercussion. Not everyone wishes to be made a martyr.
I agree people who want to keep secret is free to pursue it.
For me keeping a secret is not without cost, its a burden, significant amount of work and inconvenience.
I'm personally fine with you not bothering with your own privacy if you feel it isn't worth the burden.
Privacy advocates see that sort of thinking as harmful though. If it becomes the 'standard' way of thinking it easier to pass laws that violate privacy. So "our" first step is trying to convince people that the right to privacy is important, even if they don't personally care about their own privacy.
It's a bit nonsensical to ask someone to fight for privacy rights when they don't care about their own privacy. It's easier to fight for something if they actually care about it, which is why you see so many privacy advocates (like myself) trying to convince you your privacy is important. I'm fine with you not caring about your own privacy due to the burden of keeping it, but I beg, not ask, that you care enough to defend the rights of people who find the burden worth carrying.
What do you think is the most convincing argument to this end that I can read in a tea break?
An appeal to historical abuses works for some - but others see that sort of abuse "not being possible in the modern day". In my opinion, that is naive since many countries are still actively oppressing minority views... it's literally happening in the modern day. Just perhaps not in their country yet. =\
As Adam D. Moore said: "Consider someone’s sexual or medical history. Imagine someone visiting a library to learn about alternative lifestyles not accepted by the majority." I use examples such as: Have you ever seen a therapist? Taken an anger management class? Have had an STD? Are you LGBT or supportive of LGBT rights?
Depending what country someone lives in - inquiring about their beliefs on "touchy subjects" can be a good one. If they refuse to tell, then they have something they wish to keep private. If they do tell - is there someone they wouldn't tell? If so, why not? (eg: Would they tell talk to their boss about politics?)
Those are the most TL;DR versions I could make for each of them. The goal is to get them to see privacy from the viewpoint of a minority - and especially from a minority group who are persecuted, ostracized, harmed, or killed for having their beliefs. Privacy is literally the difference between life and death for people across the globe and people who have no felt their life has ever been in danger due to the lack of privacy should be thankful.
In a world where people truly have "nothing to hide" then there would be no reason to look.
And besides, though you might very well prefer not to have secrets, you should extend that to those watching you.
To keep the analogy don't we need to add two provisos though: you can't tell anyone about it or you lose your job and face prosecution (unless you can convince the CPS that there's a case against me, then you have your say in court); and you'll need to convince a judge that you have a legal need, that also serves the public interest, to observe me.
>Our email conversations with our friends and family, our video chats etc should be private. (They're not of course, they're all intercepted and stored forever, but they should be private). //
AIUI the UK Investigatory Powers Act is storing domains visited for a limited time and requires a warrant to enable access, access then only being granted to officers of a particular standing (so they can't pass the details around and the named officer is responsible if the info is leaked). Am I getting the wrong message? I've not had time to read the Act yet.
Security services are almost certainly able to access that data, but then that's been true for a long time and is covered by far more generic laws, the IPA isn't addressing that (is it?).
tl;dr - if I don't care if you sit and watch me watching Masterchef, or playing on Steam, or if you read my emails to customers, or see what I buy (just like you can if I go to a shop), then ... is there anything left that you can say to convince me I should be hiding what I do online. "I don't hide what I do IRL, why hide online"?